Thomas Hinds Lodge No. 58 F. & A. M. v. Presbyterian Church At Fayette
Decision Date | 09 December 1912 |
Citation | 103 Miss. 130,60 So. 66 |
Parties | THOMAS HINDS LODGE NO. 58 F. & A. M. v. PRESBYTERIAN CHURCH AT FAYETTE |
Court | Mississippi Supreme Court |
October 1912
APPEAL from the chancery court of Jefferson county, HON. J. S HICKS, Chancellor.
Suit by the Presbyterial Church of Fayette against the Thomas Hinds Lodge No. 58 F. & A. M. in which defendant filed a cross-bill. From a decree granting relief to both parties both parties appeal.
The facts are fully stated in the opinion of the court.
Reversed and remanded. Overruled.
Ernest E. Brown, for appellant.
Truly, Ratcliff & Truly, R. H. Thompson and W. R. Harper, for appellee.
No brief of counsel on either side found in record.
Argued orally by Marcellus Green, for appellant and Jeff T. Truly, R. H. Thompson and W. R. Harper, for appellee.
OPINION
In the town of Fayette, Miss., there is situated a two-story brick building which has been used jointly by appellant, Thomas Hinds Lodge No. 58, F. & A. M., and appellee, the Presbyterian Church of Fayette, Miss., since its erection in 1854, the upper story as a lodge room by appellant, and the lower story as a place of worship by appellee. In 1909 a controversy over the ownership and the right to the use of the lower story of this building having arisen, this litigation was inaugurated by appellant instituting in the circuit court an action of ejectment against the church, which suit was afterwards dismissed and an unlawful entry and detainer proceeding begun instead. Afterwards appellee filed its bill in the court below enjoining the further prosecution of this unlawful entry and detainer proceeding, and praying for one of several reliefs more particularly referred to hereafter. Appellant by answer and cross-bill denied appellee's right to the relief prayed for, and prayed that appellee's claim to the use of the lower story be canceled and possession thereof be awarded to appellant, and that it recover from appellee a reasonable rental for the use of the property since the date of the termination of appellee's lease. The The decree of the court below adjudged the title to the property to be in appellant, and denied appellee the right to the use of the building or to demand a renewal of the lease; but adjudged that it was entitled to the money expended by it in making certain repairs on the property, which will be hereinafter more fully set forth, and denied to appellant the right to recover rent for the use of the property since the termination of the lease. Both parties being dissatisfied with this decree appeal to this court, appellant by direct and appellee by cross-appeal.
The facts necessary for an understanding of the points involved herein are about as follows: In 1854 appellant was the owner of a certain lot in the town of Fayette, and was contemplating the erection of a two-story building thereon, the upper story to be used as a lodge room, and the lower to be rented for business purposes. At this time there was no Presbyterian Church in Fayette, but there was such a church at Ebenezer, in Jefferson county, several miles from Fayette. Before this building was erected, the pastor of this church, with the approval of its session, wrote a letter to appellant suggesting that the lower story "be made into a church," and bound himself, if this should be done, "to raise all funds necessary to furnish it in a handsome style, and also to pay a fair portion of the expense of building and the foundation and walls of the first story." His letter then continued as follows: Appellant's reply to this letter was embodied in the following resolution: It does not appear from the evidence, except as contained in the recital of the lease hereinafter mentioned, executed in 1876, whether or not these committees ever met and consummated the arrangements contemplated by this letter and resolution; but on September 30, 1854, appellant's minutes show that: Nothing further appears in the testimony relative to the erection of this building, and it is absolutely silent as to the right by which appellee occupied the lower story thereof until December 27, 1875. It seems to be assumed, however, by counsel on both sides, that, whether occupying as tenant or owner, appellee was chargeable with one-third of all necessary repairs made on the building.
In December, 1875, a discussion seems to have arisen between the lodge and the church relative to the payment of the amount which the church seemed to be in arrears with the lodge for repairs made by the lodge upon the building. Thereupon a committee appointed by the church to confer with a similar committee from the lodge executed the following instrument: The authority of this committee to act in this matter is now disputed by the church, but the only evidence relative thereto was the testimony of one of the members of the committee, who said that it was duly appointed by, and given authority to act for, the church. This matter seems to have been amicably adjusted, and thereafter, on the 1st day of January, 1876, the lodge executed to the church the following lease to the lower story for a period of thirty years:
...
To continue reading
Request your trial-
Mississippi Power & Light Co. v. Pitts
... ... 153 ... Cooper ... & Thomas, and B. B. Allen, all Indianola, for appellee ... Tire Co., 210 N.Y.S. 243, 214 A.D. 58 ... Where a ... case is not removable ... Favre, 119 So. 911; Thomas Hinds ... Lodge v. Presbyterian Church, 103 Miss ... ...
-
Plaza Amusement Co. v. Rothenberg
... ... Weaver, 53 ... Wash. 408; Gerner v. Church, 43 Nebr. 690, 62 N.W ... 51; Railroad Stores ... 382; Harris v. Townsend, 101 Miss. 597, 58 So ... 529; Hall v. Eastman Gardiner & Co., ... 294, 75 So. 119; Pleas v. Thomas, 75 Miss. 495; ... Greenl. Cruise tit. "Deed" ... Millsaps, 71 Miss. 12; Hines ... Lodge v. Presbyterian Church, 103 Miss. 130 ... ...
-
Pitts v. Mississippi Power & Light Co.
... ... [177 ... Miss. 289] Cooper & Thomas and B. B. Allen, all of Indianola, ... for ... 911; [177 Miss. 290] ... Thomas Hinds Lodge v. Presbyterian Church, 103 Miss ... 130, ... ...
-
Union & Planters' Bank & Trust Co. v. Corley
... ... Week Rep. 559; First African Church v. Brown, ... 147 Mass. 296; Cobbs v ... v. Graham, 80 Miss. 636; Masonic Lodge v. Presbyterian ... Church, 103 Miss. 130; 35 ... 287; Delano v ... Montague 58 Mass. 42; 2 Thompson on Real Property, sec ... ...