United States v. Williams

Decision Date22 August 2013
Docket Number12–1941,12–1949,13–1200.,Nos. 11–3437,s. 11–3437
CourtU.S. Court of Appeals — Eighth Circuit
PartiesUNITED STATES of America, Plaintiff–Appellee v. Shannon E. WILLIAMS, also known as Donald Jarmon, also known as Thumbs, Defendant–Appellant. United States of America, Plaintiff–Appellee v. $1,000.00 refunded to Mango Creek Properties, Inc. from GBS Partners, Inc. seized on January 28, 2010; $1,000.00 seized on December 22, 2009 from Spence Escrow Company from an escrow account holding money for Deshawn Hernandez; $85,120.00 in United States currency seized from safe deposit box number 29 at Pinnacle Bank on December 18, 2009; $15,545.95 seized from Pinnacle Bank Account No. 6912183410 in the name of Mango Creek Properties, Inc. on December 18, 2009; $1,445.00 in United States currency delivered to Terry Haddock by Deshawn Hernandez on May 27, 2009 and on July 6, 2009; North 91.5 Feet, West 28 Feet, Lot 6, in the North 91.5 Feet of Lot 7, Block 4, Parkers Addition, as surveyed, platted and recorded in Douglas County, Nebraska, commonly known as 1923 N. 27th Street, Omaha, Nebraska, titled in the name of Shannon Williams; Lot 12, Block 2, Hitchcock's 1st Addition, an Addition to the City of Omaha, as surveyed, platted and recorded in Douglas County, Nebraska, commonly known as 3744 Lake Street, Omaha, Nebraska, titled in the name of Shannon Williams; 3181 Pennington Cir. SW, Atlanta, Georgia, as surveyed, platted and recorded in Fulton County, Georgia, commonly known as 3181 Pennington Cir. SW, Atlanta, Georgia, titled in the name of E Zone Investments, LLC; Hastings & Heydens 3rd Add, Lot 14, Block 0, Lots 13 & 82 x 120, as surveyed, platted and recorded in Douglas County, Nebraska, commonly known as 2444 Browne Street, Omaha, Nebraska, titled in the name of Deshawn Hernandez; Fairfax, Lot 216, Block 0 40 x 134, as surveyed, platted and recorded in Douglas County, Nebraska, commonly known as 3721 N. 39th Street, Omaha, Nebraska, titled in the name of Mango Creek Properties, Inc.; Mossman & Wilson Add, Lot 106, Block 0, Lot 106, Block 0, as surveyed, platted and recorded in Douglas County, Nebraska, commonly known as 2205 N. 39th Street, Omaha, Nebraska, titled in the name of Shannon Williams; Wilson Carl C2nd Add, Lot 20, Block 0 42 X 129.2, as surveyed, platted and recorded in Douglas County, Nebraska, commonly known as 4527 N. 36th Avenue, Omaha, Nebraska, titled in the name of E Zone Investments, LLC; Fontenelle Park, Lot 205, Block 0 40 X 130, as surveyed, platted and recorded in Douglas County, Nebraska, commonly known as 3916 N. 42nd, Omaha, Nebraska, titled in the name of E Zone Investments, LLC; Yale Place, Lot 49, Block 0EX S 5 Ft 40 X 98.2, as surveyed, platted and recorded in Douglas County, Nebraska, commonly known as 3365 Erskine Street, Omaha, Nebraska, titled in the name of E Zone Investments, LLC; West 38', East 76 Feet of Lots 16 and 17, and Lot 18, Block 4, Lowe's Subdivision, as surveyed, platted and recorded in Douglas County Nebraska, commonly known as 3106 Decatur Street, Omaha, Nebraska, titled in the name of Latreise Anderson, Defendants. Shannon E. Williams, Claimant–Appellant v. Violet Goodwin, Interested party. United States of America, Plaintiff–Appellee v. $1,000.00 refunded to Mango Creek Properties, Inc. from GBS Partners, Inc. seized on January 28, 2010; $1,000.00 seized on December 22, 2009 from Spence Escrow Company from an escrow account holding money for Deshawn Hernandez; $85,120.00 in United States currency seized from safe deposit box number 29 at Pinnacle Bank on December 18, 2009; $15,545.95 seized from Pinnacle Bank Account No. 6912183410 in the name of Mango Creek Properties, Inc. on December 18, 2009; $1,445.00 in United States currency delivered to Terry Haddock by Deshawn Hernandez on May 27, 2009 and on July 6, 2009; North 91.5 Feet, West 28 Feet, Lot 6, in the North 91.5 Feet of Lot 7, Block 4, Parkers Addition, as surveyed, platted and recorded in Douglas County, Nebraska, commonly known as 1923 N. 27th Street, Omaha, Nebraska, titled in the name of Shannon Williams; Lot 12, Block 2, Hitchcock's 1st Addition, an Addition to the City of Omaha, as surveyed, platted and recorded in Douglas County, Nebraska, commonly known as 3744 Lake Street, Omaha, Nebraska, titled in the name of Shannon Williams; 3181 Pennington Cir SW, Atlanta, Georgia, as surveyed, platted and recorded in Fulton County, Georgia, commonly known as 3181 Pennington Cir. SW, Atlanta, Georgia, titled in the name of E Zone Investments, LLC; Hastings & Heydens 3rd Add, Lot 14, Block 0, Lots 13 & 82 x 120, as surveyed, platted and recorded in Douglas County, Nebraska, commonly known as 2444 Browne Street, Omaha, Nebraska, titled in the name of Deshawn Hernandez; Fairfax, Lot 216, Block 0 40 x 134, as surveyed, platted and recorded in Douglas County, Nebraska, commonly known as 3721 N. 39th Street, Omaha, Nebraska, titled in the name of Mango Creek Properties, Inc.; Mossman & Wilson Add, Lot 106, Block 0, Lot 106, Block 0, as surveyed, platted and recorded in Douglas County, Nebraska, commonly known as 2205 N. 39th Street, Omaha, Nebraska, titled in the name of Shannon Williams; Wilson Carl C2nd Add, Lot 20, Block 0 42 X 129.2, as surveyed, platted and recorded in Douglas County, Nebraska, commonly known as 4527 N. 36th Avenue, Omaha, Nebraska, titled in the name of E Zone Investments, LLC; Fontenelle Park, Lot 205, Block 0 40 X 130, as surveyed, platted and recorded in Douglas County, Nebraska, commonly known as 3916 N. 42nd, Omaha, Nebraska, titled in the name of E Zone Investments, LLC; Yale Place, Lot 49, Block 0EX S 5 Ft 40 X 98.2, as surveyed, platted and recorded in Douglas County, Nebraska, commonly known as 3365 Erskine Street, Omaha, Nebraska, titled in the name of E Zone Investments, LLC; West 38', East 76 Feet of Lots 16 and 17, and Lot 18, Block 4, Lowe's Subdivision, as surveyed, platted and recorded in Douglas County Nebraska, commonly known as 3106 Decatur Street, Omaha, Nebraska, titled in the name of Latreise Anderson, Defendants. Shannon E. Williams, Claimant–Appellant Violet Goodwin, Interested party. United States of America, Plaintiff–Appellee v. $1,000.00 refunded to Mango Creek Properties, Inc. from GBS Partners, Inc. seized on January 28, 2010; $1,000.00 seized on December 22, 2009 from Spence Escrow Company from an escrow account holding money for Deshawn Hernandez; $85,120.00 in United States currency seized from safe deposit box number 29 at Pinnacle Bank on December 18, 2009; $15,545.95 seized from Pinnacle Bank Account No. 6912183410 in the name of Mango Creek Properties, Inc. on December 18, 2009; $1,445.00 in United States currency delivered to Terry Haddock by Deshawn Hernandez on May 27, 2009 and on July 6, 2009; North 91.5 Feet, West 28 Feet, Lot 6, in the North 91.5 Feet of Lot 7, Block 4, Parkers Addition, as surveyed, platted and recorded in Douglas County, Nebraska, commonly known as 1923 N. 27th Street, Omaha, Nebraska, titled in the name of Shannon Williams; Lot 12, Block 2, Hitchcock's 1st Addition, an Addition to the City of Omaha, as surveyed, platted and recorded in Douglas County, Nebraska, commonly known as 3744 Lake Street, Omaha, Nebraska, titled in the name of Shannon Williams; 3181 Pennington Cir SW, Atlanta, Georgia, as surveyed, platted and recorded in Fulton County, Georgia, commonly known as 3181 Pennington Cir. SW, Atlanta, Georgia, titled in the name of E Zone Investments, LLC; Hastings & Heydens 3rd Add, Lot 14, Block 0, Lots 13 & 82 x 120, as surveyed, platted and recorded in Douglas County, Nebraska, commonly known as 2444 Browne Street, Omaha, Nebraska, titled in the name of Deshawn Hernandez; Fairfax, Lot 216, Block 0 40 x 134, as surveyed, platted and recorded in Douglas County, Nebraska, commonly known as 3721 N. 39th Street, Omaha, Nebraska, titled in the name of Mango Creek Properties, Inc.; Mossman & Wilson Add, Lot 106, Block 0, Lot 106, Block 0, as surveyed, platted and recorded in Douglas County, Nebraska, commonly known as 2205 N. 39th Street, Omaha, Nebraska, titled in the name of Shannon Williams; Wilson Carl C2nd Add, Lot 20, Block 0 42 X 129.2, as surveyed, platted and recorded in Douglas County, Nebraska, commonly known as 4527 N. 36th Avenue, Omaha, Nebraska, titled in the name of E Zone Investments, LLC; Fontenelle Park, Lot 205, Block 0 40 X 130, as surveyed, platted and recorded in Douglas County, Nebraska, commonly known as 3916 N. 42nd, Omaha, Nebraska, titled in the name of E Zone Investments, LLC; Yale Place, Lot 49, Block 0EX S 5 Ft 40 X 98.2, as surveyed, platted and recorded in Douglas County, Nebraska, commonly known as 3365 Erskine Street, Omaha, Nebraska, titled in the name of E Zone Investments, LLC; West 38', East 76 Feet of Lots 16 and 17, and Lot 18, Block 4, Lowe's Subdivision, as surveyed, platted and recorded in Douglas County Nebraska, commonly known as 3106 Decatur Street, Omaha, Nebraska, titled in the name of Latreise Anderson, Defendants. Shannon E. Williams, Claimant–Appellant.

720 F.3d 674

UNITED STATES of America, Plaintiff–Appellee
v.
Shannon E. WILLIAMS, also known as Donald Jarmon, also known as Thumbs, Defendant–Appellant.

United States of America, Plaintiff–Appellee
v.
$1,000.00 refunded to Mango Creek Properties, Inc. from GBS Partners, Inc. seized on January 28, 2010; $1,000.00 seized on December 22, 2009 from Spence Escrow Company from an escrow account holding money for Deshawn Hernandez; $85,120.00 in United States currency seized from safe deposit box number 29 at Pinnacle Bank on December 18, 2009; $15,545.95 seized from Pinnacle Bank Account No. 6912183410 in the name of Mango Creek Properties, Inc. on December 18, 2009; $1,445.00 in United States currency delivered to Terry Haddock by Deshawn Hernandez on May 27, 2009 and on July 6, 2009; North 91.5 Feet, West 28 Feet, Lot 6, in the North 91.5 Feet of Lot 7, Block 4, Parkers Addition, as surveyed, platted and recorded in Douglas County, Nebraska, commonly known as 1923 N. 27th Street, Omaha, Nebraska, titled in the name of Shannon Williams; Lot 12, Block 2, Hitchcock's 1st Addition, an Addition to the City of Omaha, as surveyed, platted and recorded in Douglas County, Nebraska, commonly known as 3744 Lake Street, Omaha, Nebraska, titled in the name of Shannon Williams; 3181 Pennington Cir.
SW, Atlanta, Georgia, as surveyed, platted and recorded in Fulton County, Georgia, commonly known as 3181 Pennington Cir. SW, Atlanta, Georgia, titled in the name of E Zone Investments, LLC; Hastings & Heydens 3rd Add, Lot 14, Block 0, Lots 13 & 82 x 120, as surveyed, platted and recorded in Douglas County, Nebraska, commonly known as 2444 Browne Street, Omaha, Nebraska, titled in the name of Deshawn Hernandez; Fairfax, Lot 216, Block 0 40 x 134, as surveyed, platted and recorded in Douglas County, Nebraska, commonly known as 3721 N. 39th Street, Omaha, Nebraska, titled in the name of Mango Creek Properties, Inc.; Mossman & Wilson Add, Lot 106, Block 0, Lot 106, Block 0, as surveyed, platted and recorded in Douglas County, Nebraska, commonly known as 2205 N. 39th Street, Omaha, Nebraska, titled in the name of Shannon Williams; Wilson Carl C2nd Add, Lot 20, Block 0 42 X 129.2, as surveyed, platted and recorded in Douglas County, Nebraska, commonly known as 4527 N. 36th Avenue, Omaha, Nebraska, titled in the name of E Zone Investments, LLC; Fontenelle Park, Lot 205, Block 0 40 X 130, as surveyed, platted and recorded in Douglas County, Nebraska, commonly known as 3916 N. 42nd, Omaha, Nebraska, titled in the name of E Zone Investments, LLC; Yale Place, Lot 49, Block 0EX S 5 Ft 40 X 98.2, as surveyed, platted and recorded in Douglas County, Nebraska, commonly known as 3365 Erskine Street, Omaha, Nebraska, titled in the name of E Zone Investments, LLC; West 38', East 76 Feet of Lots 16 and 17, and Lot 18, Block 4, Lowe's Subdivision, as surveyed, platted and recorded in Douglas County Nebraska, commonly known as 3106 Decatur Street, Omaha, Nebraska, titled in the name of Latreise Anderson, Defendants.
Shannon E. Williams, Claimant–Appellant
v.
Violet Goodwin, Interested party.

United States of America, Plaintiff–Appellee
v.
$1,000.00 refunded to Mango Creek Properties, Inc. from GBS Partners, Inc. seized on January 28, 2010; $1,000.00 seized on December 22, 2009 from Spence Escrow Company from an escrow account holding money for Deshawn Hernandez; $85,120.00 in United States currency seized from safe deposit box number 29 at Pinnacle Bank on December 18, 2009; $15,545.95 seized from Pinnacle Bank Account No. 6912183410 in the name of Mango Creek Properties, Inc. on December 18, 2009; $1,445.00 in United States currency delivered to Terry Haddock by Deshawn Hernandez on May 27, 2009 and on July 6, 2009; North 91.5 Feet, West 28 Feet, Lot 6, in the North 91.5 Feet of Lot 7, Block 4, Parkers Addition, as surveyed, platted and recorded in Douglas County, Nebraska, commonly known as 1923 N. 27th Street, Omaha, Nebraska, titled in the name of Shannon Williams; Lot 12, Block 2, Hitchcock's 1st Addition, an Addition to the City of Omaha, as surveyed, platted and recorded in Douglas County, Nebraska, commonly known as 3744 Lake Street, Omaha, Nebraska, titled in the name of Shannon Williams; 3181 Pennington Cir SW, Atlanta, Georgia, as surveyed, platted and recorded in Fulton County, Georgia, commonly known as 3181 Pennington Cir.
SW, Atlanta, Georgia, titled in the name of E Zone Investments, LLC; Hastings & Heydens 3rd Add, Lot 14, Block 0, Lots 13 & 82 x 120, as surveyed, platted and recorded in Douglas County, Nebraska, commonly known as 2444 Browne Street, Omaha, Nebraska, titled in the name of Deshawn Hernandez; Fairfax, Lot 216, Block 0 40 x 134, as surveyed, platted and recorded in Douglas County, Nebraska, commonly known as 3721 N. 39th Street, Omaha, Nebraska, titled in the name of Mango Creek Properties, Inc.; Mossman & Wilson Add, Lot 106, Block 0, Lot 106, Block 0, as surveyed, platted and recorded in Douglas County, Nebraska, commonly known as 2205 N. 39th Street, Omaha, Nebraska, titled in the name of Shannon Williams; Wilson Carl C2nd Add, Lot 20, Block 0 42 X 129.2, as surveyed, platted and recorded in Douglas County, Nebraska, commonly known as 4527 N. 36th Avenue, Omaha, Nebraska, titled in the name of E Zone Investments, LLC; Fontenelle Park, Lot 205, Block 0 40 X 130, as surveyed, platted and recorded in Douglas County, Nebraska, commonly known as 3916 N. 42nd, Omaha, Nebraska, titled in the name of E Zone Investments, LLC; Yale Place, Lot 49, Block 0EX S 5 Ft 40 X 98.2, as surveyed, platted and recorded in Douglas County, Nebraska, commonly known as 3365 Erskine Street, Omaha, Nebraska, titled in the name of E Zone Investments, LLC; West 38', East 76 Feet of Lots 16 and 17, and Lot 18, Block 4, Lowe's Subdivision, as surveyed, platted and recorded in Douglas County Nebraska, commonly known as 3106 Decatur Street, Omaha, Nebraska, titled in the name of Latreise Anderson, Defendants.
Shannon E. Williams, Claimant–Appellant
Violet Goodwin, Interested party.

United States of America, Plaintiff–Appellee
v.
$1,000.00 refunded to Mango Creek Properties, Inc. from GBS Partners, Inc. seized on January 28, 2010; $1,000.00 seized on December 22, 2009 from Spence Escrow Company from an escrow account holding money for Deshawn Hernandez; $85,120.00 in United States currency seized from safe deposit box number 29 at Pinnacle Bank on December 18, 2009; $15,545.95 seized from Pinnacle Bank Account No. 6912183410 in the name of Mango Creek Properties, Inc. on December 18, 2009; $1,445.00 in United States currency delivered to Terry Haddock by Deshawn Hernandez on May 27, 2009 and on July 6, 2009; North 91.5 Feet, West 28 Feet, Lot 6, in the North 91.5 Feet of Lot 7, Block 4, Parkers Addition, as surveyed, platted and recorded in Douglas County, Nebraska, commonly known as 1923 N. 27th Street, Omaha, Nebraska, titled in the name of Shannon Williams; Lot 12, Block 2, Hitchcock's 1st Addition, an Addition to the City of Omaha, as surveyed, platted and recorded in Douglas County, Nebraska, commonly known as 3744 Lake Street, Omaha, Nebraska, titled in the name of Shannon Williams; 3181 Pennington Cir SW, Atlanta, Georgia, as surveyed, platted and recorded in Fulton County, Georgia, commonly known as 3181 Pennington Cir.
SW, Atlanta, Georgia, titled in the name of E Zone Investments, LLC; Hastings & Heydens 3rd Add, Lot 14, Block 0, Lots 13 & 82 x 120, as surveyed, platted and recorded in Douglas County, Nebraska, commonly known as 2444 Browne Street, Omaha, Nebraska, titled in the name of Deshawn Hernandez; Fairfax, Lot 216, Block 0 40 x 134, as surveyed, platted and recorded in Douglas County, Nebraska, commonly known as 3721 N. 39th Street, Omaha, Nebraska, titled in the name of Mango Creek Properties, Inc.; Mossman & Wilson Add, Lot 106, Block 0, Lot 106, Block 0, as surveyed, platted and recorded in Douglas County, Nebraska, commonly known as 2205 N. 39th Street, Omaha, Nebraska, titled in the name of Shannon Williams; Wilson Carl C2nd Add, Lot 20, Block 0 42 X 129.2, as surveyed, platted and recorded in Douglas County, Nebraska, commonly known as 4527 N. 36th Avenue, Omaha, Nebraska, titled in the name of E Zone Investments, LLC; Fontenelle Park, Lot 205, Block 0 40 X 130, as surveyed, platted and recorded in Douglas County, Nebraska, commonly known as 3916 N. 42nd, Omaha, Nebraska, titled in the name of E Zone Investments, LLC; Yale Place, Lot 49, Block 0EX S 5 Ft 40 X 98.2, as surveyed, platted and recorded in Douglas County, Nebraska, commonly known as 3365 Erskine Street, Omaha, Nebraska, titled in the name of E Zone Investments, LLC; West 38', East 76 Feet of Lots 16 and 17, and Lot 18, Block 4, Lowe's Subdivision, as surveyed, platted and recorded in Douglas County Nebraska, commonly known as 3106 Decatur Street, Omaha, Nebraska, titled in the name of Latreise Anderson, Defendants.
Shannon E. Williams, Claimant–Appellant.

Nos. 11–3437, 12–1941, 12–1949, 13–1200.

United States Court of Appeals,
Eighth Circuit.

Submitted: Feb. 13, 2013.
Filed: July 11, 2013.

Rehearing and Rehearing En Banc Denied Aug. 22, 2013.


[720 F.3d 682]


James Edward Reisinger, of Omaha, NE, for appellant.

Robert C. Sigler, USA, of Omaha, NE, for appellee.


Before SMITH, MELLOY, and BENTON, Circuit Judges.

MELLOY, Circuit Judge.

Shannon Williams was indicted and convicted by jury of conspiring to distribute and possess with the intent to distribute 1000 kilograms or more of marijuana and of laundering the related proceeds. The indictment also contained a criminal forfeiture count for certain real and tangible properties obtained as a result of the conspiracy. After Williams's trial, both Williams and the government moved to dismiss the forfeiture count—Williams with prejudice and the government without prejudice—due to a procedural error. The district court denied Williams's motion and granted the government's motion, and the government subsequently instituted a civil in rem...

To continue reading

Request your trial
51 cases
  • Williams v. Rensch
    • United States
    • U.S. District Court — District of Nebraska
    • May 6, 2015
    ...found, "[a]t all times, Williams was represented by either [Eric] Whitner or his cocounsel, attorney Steve Lefler—not Haddock." Williams, 720 F.3d at 683. In January 2009, Williams caused $15,000 to be paid to Haddock for legal services that Haddock had provided to Conway and another of Wil......
  • United States v. Streb
    • United States
    • U.S. District Court — Southern District of Iowa
    • August 10, 2020
    ...of the Government's.C. Trial Management Trial management falls well within the discretion of the trial court. United States v. Williams , 720 F.3d 674, 692 (8th Cir. 2013). Indeed, the Federal Rules of Evidence expressly permit—in fact, instruct—the trial court to "exercise reasonable contr......
  • Hamilton v. Lee
    • United States
    • U.S. District Court — Eastern District of New York
    • March 27, 2015
    ...L.Ed.2d 49 (1991) (fingerprinting is a natural part of “the administrative steps incident to arrest”); see also United States v. Williams, 720 F.3d 674, 698 (8th Cir.2013) (“[T]he Supreme Court's concerns regarding confrontation in Melendez–Diaz [v. Massachusetts, 557 U.S. 305, 129 S.Ct. 25......
  • Langbord v. U.S. Dep't of the Treasury
    • United States
    • U.S. Court of Appeals — Third Circuit
    • April 17, 2015
    ...for making final determination as to misuse of federal grant funds does not prevent later recovery of funds); United States v. Williams, 720 F.3d 674, 702 (8th Cir.2013), cert. denied , ––––U.S. ––––, 134 S.Ct. 1337, 188 L.Ed.2d 345 (2014) (failing to follow criminal forfeiture procedures a......
  • Request a trial to view additional results
3 books & journal articles
  • THE LIFE AND LEGAL LEGACY OF JUSTICE STEVEN L. ZINTER.
    • United States
    • South Dakota Law Review Vol. 65 No. 2, June 2020
    • June 22, 2020
    ...6-8, 875 N.W.2d 25, 26-27. (207.) Id. [paragraph] 8, 875 N.W.2d at 27. (208.) Id. (citing United States v. Williams, 720 F.3d 674, 699 (8th Cir. 2013); United States v. Dale, 494 F. App'x 317, 318 (4th Cir. 2012); United States v. Thornton, 209 F. App'x 297, 299 (4th Cir. (209.) Id. [paragr......
  • Confidentiality and conflicts of interest: a guide for South Dakota lawyers.
    • United States
    • South Dakota Law Review Vol. 59 No. 3, September - September 2014
    • September 22, 2014
    ...93-1 (1993) [hereinafter Formal Op. 93-1], (55.) South Dakota Rules of Prof'l Conduct R. 5.4(c) (2004). (56.) United States v. Williams, 720 F.3d 674, 688 (8th Cir. 2013) (citing RESTATEMENT (THIRD) of Law Governing Lawyers [section] 14 cmt. c (57.) South Dakota Rules of Prof'l Conduct R. 1......
  • A Patch with the Dev-il: How the Development of Autonomous Vehicle Software Will Challenge Attorney-Client Privilege
    • United States
    • Georgetown Journal of Legal Ethics No. 34-4, October 2021
    • October 1, 2021
    ..., 77 HARV. L. R. 730, 730 (1964). 58. Id. 59. Id. 60. In re LeFande, 919 F.3d 554, 563 (D.C. Cir. 2019). 61. United States v. Williams, 720 F.3d 674, 688 89 (8th Cir. 2013) (the attorney participated in the conspiracy with the awareness of law enforcement and provided them with evidence tha......

VLEX uses login cookies to provide you with a better browsing experience. If you click on 'Accept' or continue browsing this site we consider that you accept our cookie policy. ACCEPT