Universal Caribbean Establishment v. Bard
| Decision Date | 24 May 1989 |
| Docket Number | No. 88-0358,88-0358 |
| Citation | 14 Fla. L. Weekly 1281,543 So.2d 447 |
| Parties | 14 Fla. L. Weekly 1281 UNIVERSAL CARIBBEAN ESTABLISHMENT, d/b/a Jolly Beach Resort, a Liechtenstein corporation, Appellant, v. Brian BARD and Nancy Bard, his wife, and Jolly Beach Ltd., Inc., a Florida corporation, Appellees. |
| Court | Florida District Court of Appeals |
Richard Nichols and Marilyn Holifield of Holland & Knight, Miami, for appellant.
Arnold R. Ginsberg of Horton, Perse & Ginsberg, and Broad and Cassel, Miami, for appellees-Bard.
The order appealed herein denied the defendant's motion to dismiss for lack of personal jurisdiction and to quash service of process over the appellant, Universal Caribbean Establishment d/b/a Jolly Beach Resort, a Liechtenstein corporation, thus subjecting the corporation to the jurisdiction of the courts of Florida in this personal injury suit.
The appellees, Connecticut residents, were guests at the resort owned by appellant in Antigua, West Indies. Their reservations for this resort were booked through Jolly Beach, Limited, a Florida corporation (hereinafter referred to as "Limited"). While at the resort, appellee Brian Bard suffered severe personal injury. The Bards brought suit in Broward County Circuit court against appellant Universal Caribbean and Limited. Service on Universal Caribbean was made pursuant to section 48.081(5), Florida Statutes (1987) on Jack Mermod, as business agent for Universal Caribbean. Mr. Mermod is president of Limited and appellees alleged that Limited was the business agent for Universal Caribbean and through which Universal Caribbean maintained a business office in the state. Service was also made on Universal Caribbean through the issuance of letters rogatory which were served on the corporation in Liechtenstein.
One-third of Limited's stock is owned by Jack Mermod and two-thirds is owned by Universal Air Tours, another corporation based in Liechtenstein. Dr. Alfred Erhardt is a shareholder in both Universal Air Tours and in Universal Caribbean. The record does not reflect whether there are other stockholders in either of the Universal corporations. However, one of the sales brochures indicates Dr. Erhardt is the "owner" of the resort hotel in Antigua. Dr. Erhardt is also president of Universal Caribbean, and he made a loan of $115,000.00 to capitalize Limited. Mr. Mermod was a personal friend of Dr. Erhardt's who worked for the Universal Caribbean resort. He and Dr. Erhardt decided to set up Limited in Florida to tap the lucrative tourist market in the United States from which Universal Caribbean had not been able to generate much business prior to the formation of Limited.
Limited's business consists of being a tour operator solely for Universal Caribbean's Antigua resort. It is the largest booking agent in the United States for Universal and books approximately 20,000 reservations per year. While the resort also deals with other tour operators, Limited deals only with Universal Caribbean. In fact, Limited advertises that it is the tour agent for "our own hotel." Dr. Erhardt approved and helped work on these advertising brochures. Universal Caribbean approved all of the brochures, and the stationery of Limited uses the same logo as Universal Caribbean. One of the brochures prepared by Mr. Mermod and Dr. Erhardt states that "when booking Jolly Beach, you book directly with the hotel as tour operator." All of these materials were prepared with the permission and approval of Universal Caribbean. Both Dr. Erhardt and the hotel managers come to the United States occasionally, and, while here, they meet with Mr. Mermod and visit Limited's office. Furthermore, Limited has an employee at the resort to assist guests.
Limited prepares tour packages from hotel room rates given to it by Universal Caribbean. It puts a profit on the total package and collects these monies from various travel agents with whom it deals. It is then invoiced by...
To continue reading
Request your trial
-
Sun Trust Bank v. Sun International Hotels, Ltd.
...or not the cause of action "arises from" the activity within the state. § 48.193(2), Fla. Stat. (2001); Universal Caribbean Establishment v. Bard, 543 So.2d 447, 448 (Fla. 4th DCA 1989). a. Sun Here, despite Sun Hotels' contention that it is not engaged in "substantial and not isolated acti......
-
Krauser v. Evollution Ip Holdings, Inc.
...satisfy section 48.193(2)'s requirements also necessitates a finding that minimum contacts exist. See Universal Caribbean Establishment v. Bard, 543 So.2d 447, 448 (Fla.Dist.Ct.App.1989). Therefore, the analysis of jurisdiction under section 48.193(2) and the Due Process clause merge. As th......
-
Exhibit Icons, LLC v. Xp Companies, LLC
...satisfy section 48.193(2)'s requirements also necessitates a finding that minimum contacts exist. See Universal Caribbean Estab. v. Bard, 543 So.2d 447, 448 (Fla.Dist.Ct.App.1989). Therefore, the analysis of jurisdiction under section 48.193(2) and the Due Process clause merge. As there is ......
-
iSocial Media Inc. v. Bwin.party Digital Entm't PLC
...to serve only the parent's needs," Gadea v. Star Cruises, Ltd., 949 So.2d 1143(Fla. 3rd DCA 2007); Universal Caribbean Establishment v. Bard, 543 So.2d 447 (Fla. 4th DCA 1989); Development Corp. of Palm Beach v. WBC Construction, L.L.C., 925 So.2d 1156, 1161-62 (Fla. 4th DCA 2006). This req......
-
Chapter § 1.03 TRAVEL ABROAD, SUE AT HOME
...(no jurisdiction over parent hotel based solicitation of subsidiary in the forum). Florida: Universal Caribbean Establishment v. Bard, 543 So. 2d 447 (Fla. App. 1989) (jurisdiction based upon activities of subsidiary corporations in the forum). New York: Taca Intl. Airlines v. Rolls-Royce o......