Ward v. St. Louis County
| Decision Date | 06 November 1944 |
| Docket Number | 38359 |
| Citation | 183 S.W.2d 68,353 Mo. 529 |
| Parties | John W. Ward, Jr., Plaintiff in Error, v. County of St. Louis, Defendant in Error |
| Court | Missouri Supreme Court |
Writ of Error to Circuit Court of County of St. Louis; Hon Julius R. Nolte, Judge.
Affirmed.
Joseph A. Falzone and J. Corder Delworth for plaintiff in error.
(1) The plaintiff as justice of the peace may exercise such powers and receive such compensation as is or may be provided by law. Art. 6, Sec. 37, Const. of Mo. (2) Prior to November 1 1939, plaintiff, as an elected and qualified justice of the peace, was compensated for his services as such by the collection and retention of costs allowed by law. Sec. 11778 R.S. 1929. (3) Plaintiff as an elected and qualified justice of the peace is authorized, but is not duty bound to solemnize marriages, as an officer of the state, and is authorized by law to collect, receive and retain a fee of $ 2 for each marriage solemnized. Secs. 3363, 13400, R.S. 1939. (4) Sections 3363 and 13400 authorizing plaintiff as justice of the peace to solemnize marriages and to receive and retain a fee of $ 2 for each has not been repealed. Laws 1939, p. 340. (5) Article 8, Chapter 11, Sections 2752-2758, 1939, should be interpreted in accordance with the intent and purpose of the General Assembly; should be construed to harmonize and give effect, and was intended to be consistent and harmonious. Cairo Bridge Co. v. Mitchell, 181 S.W.2d 496; Metropolitan Life Ins. Co. v. Scheuffler, 180 S.W.2d 742; State ex rel. v. Green, 180 S.W.2d 110. (6) Article 8, Chapter 11, R.S. 1939, does not and was not intended to substitute a salary for, or to deprive plaintiff and other justices of St. Louis County of the right to collect and retain $ 2 fee for solemnizing a marriage and does not and was not intended to require plaintiff to account for and pay over to the county treasurer the $ 2 collected for solemnizing a marriage. Art. 8, R.S. 1939; Secs. 3363, 13400, R.S. 1939; St. Louis v. Sommers, 50 S.W. 102; Smith v. Pettis County, 136 S.W.2d l.c. 288. (7) Article 8, Chapter 11, Sections 2752-2758, R.S. 1939, is a Revisions Act and therefore, the title to the revised act, Article 8, Chapter 10, R.S. 1929, becomes a part of said 1939 Act. Laws 1939, p. 340; Laws 1915, p. 324.
Erwin F. Vetter for defendant in error.
A justice of the peace must account for all fees received "by virtue of his office," and this includes fees charged for the solemnization of marriages. Secs. 2753, 2755, R.S. 1939; State ex rel. v. Gass, 317 Mo. 744, 296 S.W. 431.
Action by plaintiff Ward for a declaratory judgment construing certain sections of the statute. As a justice of the peace in Clayton Township, St. Louis County, he is paid a salary of $ 2000. [Sec. 2752, R.S. 1939.] He is required to pay to the county treasurer fees collected by him. However, he contends that he is not required to account for fees collected for solemnizing contracts of marriage. The trial court ruled that he was required to do so.
Plaintiff may solemnize contracts of marriage. [Sec. 3363, R.S. 1939.] He is not required to do so. If he does so, he is allowed $ 2.00 for the service (Sec. 13400, R.S. 1939), which fee is collected because he is a justice of the peace and by virtue of his office. [State ex rel. and to Use of Jasper County v. Gass et al., 317 Mo. 744, 296 S.W. 431, 432.] On appeal, plaintiff argues that the marriage service is not a court service and for that reason the statute does not require an accounting of fees collected for such service. The statute follows:
"Each justice of the peace shall, before entering upon the duties of his office, give bond to the state of Missouri, with two good and sufficient sureties, residents of the county, in the penal sum of two thousand dollars, conditional that he will account for and pay to the proper officer all the money received by him by virtue of his office; said bond to be approved by the county court, or the clerk in vacation, and if taken by the clerk in vacation it shall be approved or rejected by the court at the next term." [Sec. 2753, R.S. 1939.]
"Each justice of the peace shall pay over all fees collected for his services to the treasurer of the county in which he is elected every thirty days, accompanied by a statement thereof sworn to by him, and all other costs collected by said justice of the peace shall be paid by him every thirty days, accompanied by like sworn statement, to the constable of his district, who shall be responsible for...
To continue reading
Request your trial