Wells v. Del Norte School Dist. C-7
| Decision Date | 15 October 1987 |
| Docket Number | No. 85CA0246,D,C-7,85CA0246 |
| Citation | 753 P.2d 770 |
| Parties | 46 Ed. Law Rep. 795 Iris WELLS, Plaintiff-Appellant, v. DEL NORTE SCHOOL DISTRICTefendant-Appellee. . II |
| Court | Colorado Court of Appeals |
Hobbs/Bethke & Associates, Larry F. Hobbs, P.C., William P. Bethke, Vonda G. Hall, Denver, for plaintiff-appellant.
Caplan & Earnest, Alexander Halpern, Gerald A. Caplan, Boulder, for defendant-appellee.
Iris Wells (teacher) was dismissed for incompetency from her position as a tenured elementary school teacher by the defendant, Del Norte School District C-7 (school board), pursuant to the Teacher Employment Dismissal and Tenure Act of 1967, § 22-63-101, et seq., C.R.S. (1986 Cum.Supp.) (Teacher Tenure Act). The teacher seeks review, and we reverse and remand for a new hearing.
Teacher holds a general elementary teaching certificate and was the elementary school librarian until the position was eliminated because of budget difficulties. The teacher was ultimately reassigned to teach sixth grade English and Science. That reassignment was within teacher's certification, although her prior experience had been entirely confined to the lower grades. Evaluations from her performance led to the charges of incompetence filed against her and the recommendation for her dismissal.
Teacher first argues that her transfer to a position for which she is least qualified and capable predisposes a future ultimate finding of incompetence and undermines the validity of such finding. We disagree.
The power of a school board to control the transfers of teachers in its district is limited only by the express terms of the statute. Draper v. School District I, 175 Colo. 216, 486 P.2d 1048 (Colo.1971). Section 22-63-114(1), C.R.S. (1986 Cum.Supp.) of The Teacher Tenure Act provides:
"A teacher may be transferred upon the recommendation of the chief executive officer of the school district from one school, position, or grade level to another within the school district, if such transfer does not result in the assignment of the teacher to a position of employment for which he is not qualified by virtue of academic preparation and certification...."
Here, the teacher had taken academic courses in English and Science and was qualified by her certification to teach any subject in the first through sixth grades.
In our view, the legislative intent was to make the matter of transfer of teachers between positions a discretionary determination by the board if within the teacher's academic preparation and certification. See Draper, supra. Sufficient safeguards are included within the procedures of the Teacher Tenure Act to insure fair treatment. See Wheeler v. School District No. 20, 33 Colo.App. 233, 521 P.2d 178 (1973), aff'd, 188 colo. 262, 535 P.2d 206 (1975).
Teacher next argues that her due process rights were violated when, in the midst of one witness' testimony a lunch recess was taken and the hearing officer sat down to eat his meal at the restaurant table where counsel for the school board and that witness were eating. When the hearing resumed, the hearing officer explained that no other seats had been available in the restaurant, and he said that before taking the seat he had indicated he would not discuss the case. There was no evidence of any inappropriate discussion. However, the teacher and others involved in the hearing also ate in the restaurant and observed the conversations between the hearing officer and the witness during lunch. That they were disturbed by what they observed is not disputed. Thus, we agree with the teacher, not that her due process rights were in fact violated, but that this blatant appearance of impropriety casts such a doubt on the impartiality of the decision as to vitiate the proceedings.
There is a presumption of integrity, honesty, and impartiality in favor of those serving in a quasi-judicial capacity. Teacher has the burden of rebutting this presumption. Soon Yee Scott v. City of Englewood, 672 P.2d 225 (Colo.App.1983). Although the record does not show the content of the discussion, the hearing officer's ex parte lunch conversations with counsel and witnesses for the board undermine the appearance of impartiality in connection with his determination of the facts and was sufficient to overcome the presumption of regularity attendant to an administrative proceeding. See deKoevend v. Board of Education, 653 P.2d 743 (Colo.App.1982), rev'd, 688 P.2d 219 (Colo.1984).
When administrative proceedings are quasi-judicial in character, agency officials should be treated as the equivalent of judges. Hadley v. Moffat County School District RE-1, 641 P.2d 284 (Colo.App....
To continue reading
Request your trial
-
Widder v. Durango School Dist. No. 9-R
...75 S.Ct. 623, 99 L.Ed. 942 (1955) ("A fair trial in a fair tribunal is a basic requirement of due process."); Wells v. Del Norte Sch. Dist. C-7, 753 P.2d 770, 772 (Colo.App.1987) ("When administrative proceedings are quasi-judicial in nature, agency officials should be treated as the equiva......
-
Tyson v. State
...by their nature suggest partiality. See Jeffrey M. Shaman et al., Judicial Conduct and Ethics 149 (1990). In Wells v. Del Norte Sch. Dist., 753 P.2d 770 (Colo.Ct.App.1987), even an ex parte contact which involved no comment about the pending case was held to constitute such an appearance of......
-
Matter of Miller v. Source One Management, W. C. No. 4-418-173 (Colo. 12/19/2003)
...required to enter a detailed discussion of the reasons why he found the claimant's testimony credible. See Wells v. Del Norte School District C-7, 753 P.2d 770 (Colo. App. 1987). We have reviewed the record and conclude the claimant's testimony was not refuted by such hard, certain evidence......
-
Christie v. San Miguel County School Dist. R-2(J), R-2
...and transfer of teachers within its district is limited only by the express terms of the Tenure Act. Wells v. Del Norte School District C-7, 753 P.2d 770 (Colo.App.1987); see also Draper v. School District No. 1, 175 Colo. 216, 486 P.2d 1048 (1971). Section 22-63-114(1), C.R.S., of the Tenu......
-
Formal Opinion 93: Ex Parte Contacts With Government Officials, Adopted October 16, 1993, Amended February 2016
...capacity may not receive or consider ex parte materials or representations. C.R.S. § 24-4-105(14). See Wells v. Del Norte Sch. Dist. C 7, 753 P.2d 770, 772 (Colo. App. 1987). An attorney's ex parte contact in such a situation is both an ethical violation and, potentially, cause for invalida......
-
Ex Parte Communications With a Tribunal: from Both Sides
...where court president was removed from court-martial panel), cert. denied, 513 U.S. 1084 (1995); Wells v. Del Norte School District C-7, 753 P.2d 770 (Colo.App. judge who sat at restaurant table with counsel and witnesses during lunch break from hearing); Alabama Judicial Ethics Op. 99-722 ......
-
Application of the Code of Judicial Conduct to Administrative Agency Proceedings
...These courts also are designated as courts of record in CRS º 13-1-111. 3. CRS º 13-4-101. 4. Colorado Constitution, Art. IV, º 22. 5. 753 P.2d 770 (Colo.App. 1987). 6. The title to Canon 2 provides: "A Judge Should Avoid Impropriety and the Appearance of Impropriety in All the Judge's Acti......