Whidby v. Willis

• Citation: 151 Ga. 43,105 S.E. 470
• Decision Date: 14 January 1921
• Docket Number: (No. 2044.)
• Parties: WHIDBY. v. WILLIS.
• Court: Supreme Court of Georgia

151 Ga. 43

105 S.E. 470

WHIDBY.

v.WILLIS.

(No. 2044.)

Supreme Court of Georgia.

Jan. 14, 1921.

(Syllabus by Editorial Staff.)

Error from Superior Court, Richmond County; H. C. Hammond, Judge.

Action by E. C. Whidby against T. M. Willis. Judgment for defendant, and plaintiff brings error. Reversed.

Hamilton Phinizy, of Augusta, for plaintiff in error.

J. S. Watkins, of Augusta, for defendant in error.

FISH, C. J. On March 28, 1919, Emula C. Whidby brought an action against T. M. Willis for land, for damages for the cutting and removal of timber therefrom, and for mesne profits. The land is the 148-acre tract described in a conveyance from defendant to plaintiff, upon which she relies as title, a copy of which is as follows:

"Georgia, Richmond County. In consideration of $100.00, in cash paid to me by Mrs. Emula C. Whidby, and her agreement to pay my indebtedness to the Tubman Home of $1,000 and interest, I hereby bargain, sell, convey, and quitclaim to Mrs. Emula C. Whidby all that portion of the La Taste place lying on the east side of the Savannah dirt road, about fourteen and one half (14 1/2) miles from Augusta. Said tract containing 148 acres, and bounded north by Gepfert; east by Chavous and Griner, south by Griner, and west by Savannah dirt road. That portion of the La Taste place lying to the west of the Savannah road, 60 acres more or less, is not sold. I am to retain possession of the dwelling house on the property hereby conveyed on the east side of Savannah road until March 1, 1918, and I also retain the title to the crop on the place, garden, vegetables, etc., which are to be moved by me prior to March 1, 1918, and I am to use firewood from said place hereby conveyed until March 1, 1918. Witness my handand seal this 29th day of October, 1917. T. M. Willis [L. S.] Signed, sealed and delivered in the presence of: Harriet Stanfield, Hamilton Miller, Notary Public, Richmond County, Ga."

The petition was demurred to and dismissed on the ground that it failed to show that the plaintiff "had complied with her agreement of October 20, 1917, attached to the petition." Plaintiff excepted. Held, that the court erred in sustaining the demurrer. The agreement of the grantee in the conveyance to pay, in addition to the $100 paid in cash, an indebtedness of $1,000 of the grantor to the Tubman Home, is a mere obligation to pay such indebtedness as a part of the consideration, and is not a condition, there being nothing in the conveyance to indicate an...