White v. Lazzelle
Decision Date | 05 May 1925 |
Docket Number | 5291. |
Citation | 128 S.E. 303,99 W.Va. 109 |
Parties | WHITE, INTERNAL REVENUE COLLECTOR, v. LAZZELLE, CIRCUIT COURT JUDGE. |
Court | West Virginia Supreme Court |
Submitted January 14, 1925.
Rehearing Denied, with Modification, June 10, 1925.
Syllabus by the Court.
Where on appeal from a decree adjudicating the principles of the cause, the appellees move to dismiss on the ground that subsequent decrees included in the record, but not expressly appealed from, carrying out the principles of the first decree, are final and binding on the parties, and for that reason a reversal of the decree appealed from would avail nothing to the appellant; the overruling of the motion and reversal of the original decree constitutes an adjudication rendering the subsequent decrees of no validity or effect.
Mandamus will lie in such case compelling the circuit court to disregard the subsequent decrees and proceed in accordance with the decision of this court on the appeal.
Suit by Albert B. White, Internal Revenue Collector for District of West Virginia, on behalf of the United States, for mandamus to be directed to I. Grant Lazzelle, Judge of the Circuit Court of Monongalia County. Writ awarded.
T. M McIntire, Sp. Asst. U.S. Atty., of Parkersburg, for relator.
Cox & Baker, of Morgantown, for respondent.
During the year 1920 the Knob Coal Company, a corporation, became largely indebted to the federal government for taxes. December 14, 1920, the respondents J. M. G. Brown, Mary B Brown, Robert D. Hennen, Louise Reiner Hennen, Noah A. Moore Nettie E. Moore, Jesse V. Moore, and Lona W. Moore, being the owners of all the capital stock of the Knob Coal Company and the Markley-Dale Coal Company, a corporation, in consideration of the sum of $300,000, sold and delivered the same to the American Gas Coal Company, a corporation. $125,000 of the purchase price having been paid in cash, to secure the payment of the residue, the American Gas Coal Company, Knob Coal Company, and Markley-Dale Coal Company, by deed bearing date of January 3, 1921, conveyed to a trustee the properties belonging to these corporations situated in Monongalia county. On October 8, 1921, the said respondents instituted a chancery suit, in the circuit court of Monongalia county, against the American Gas Coal Company, Knob Coal Company, Markley-Dale Coal Company, and others. The bill filed therein at November rules, 1921, charged insolvency of the American Gas Coal Company, and prayed for administration of its assets. Thomas Ray Dille, a commissioner in chancery, to whom the cause was referred to ascertain and report the assets and liabilities, in the order of priority, of the American Gas Coal Company, Knob Coal Company, and Markley-Dale Coal Company, filed his report finding, inter alia, that the debt of Knob Coal Company to the government, in the sum of $38,653.90, constituted a claim against the assets of this corporation superior to that of said respondents, under the deed of trust, amounting to $171,993.25. Sustaining exceptions of the said respondents to the commissioner's finding, by decree of November 27, 1922, the circuit court decreed that the claim of said respondents under the deed of trust was superior to that of the government against the assets of Knob Coal Company.
January 8, 1923, a decree was entered directing special commissioners to make sale of the assets belonging to the three corporations; and, such sale having been made and reported pursuant thereto, another decree was rendered April 6, 1923, confirming the sale and directing distribution of the proceeds in accordance with the decree of November 27, 1922. June 26, 1923, an appeal and supersedeas was awarded by this court to the said decree of November 27, 1922. On February 6, 1924, the said respondents filed a written motion to dismiss the appeal and supersedeas on two grounds; one being that the decree appealed from was merely interlocutory and therefore not reviewable. To sustain this motion, which was submitted at the hearing of the case, it was argued on brief:
In passing on the ground for dismissal, that the decree appealed from was not final, Judge Lively, speaking for the court, said:
To continue reading
Request your trial