White v. Whiteway Pharmacy, Inc.
Decision Date | 07 September 1962 |
Citation | 360 S.W.2d 12,14 McCanless 449,210 Tenn. 449 |
Parties | , 210 Tenn. 449 Michael Edward WHITE and Michelle Elizabeth White by: n/f. Grace White v. WHITEWAY PHARMACY, INC. and Liberty Mutual Insurance Co. |
Court | Tennessee Supreme Court |
William A. McTighe, Memphis, for appellants.
James R. Winchester, Winchester & Winchester, Memphis, for appellees.
The petitioners, the minor children and the dependents of Jean Evelyn White Pride filed their petition in the Chancery Court of Shelby County, seeking to recover benefits under the Tennessee Workmen's Compensation Act, which they claim accrued to them as the result of the death of their mother while at work for the defendant Whiteway Pharmacy, Inc. The Liberty Mutual Insurance Company is the insurance carrier for its co-defendant Whiteway Pharmacy, Inc.
After hearing all of the evidence in the case the Chancellor wrote a full and exhaustive memorandum and said in part as follows:
'Before there can be a recovery under the Workmen's Compensation Act it is necessary that the injury or death arise out of and during the course of employment of the employee. The terms 'arising out of' and 'in the course of' employment are not synonymous. An employee may suffer an injury during the course of his employment but at the same time it does not necessarily follow that the injury arose out of and in the course of his employment * * *.
T.C.A. § 50-902(d) states:
"Injury' and 'personal injury,' shall mean any injury by accident arising out of and in the course of employment * * *.'
The Chancellor held under the facts presented in this case that the deceased suffered an accidental injury during the course of her employment but said injury did not arise out of her employment.
The facts upon which the trial court based its decision as disclosed by the record are that Jean Evelyn White Pride was the mother of the petitioners herein and was the wife of Tim Pride, both of whom had been employees of Whiteway Pharmacy. However, in December, 1958, Tim Pride was discharged from said employment. Jean Pride continued to work for said defendant and was so employed and at work on July 15, 1959, when her husband, Tim Pride, stabbed and killed her.
According to the proof the deceased and her husband had separated as a result of his relations with another woman, whose child he had allegedly fathered. He accused her of disloyalty and said that on July 14, 1959, he found her in company of another man and that on the following morning he went to her place of employment and stabbed her to death with a butcher knife. He went into the Whiteway Pharmacy on the morning of July 15, 1959, at about 8:00 o'clock and was temporarily detained by the owner of the Pharmacy. However, the telephone rang and when the owner was answering the phone he, Tim Pride, proceeded to the basement of the Pharmacy where the deceased was working to discuss her conduct about running around with another man.
The testimony of Tim Pride is:
...
To continue reading
Request your trial-
Fragale v. Armory Maintenance
...and this fact was cited as one of the major circumstances connecting the situation with the employment and White v. Whiteway Pharmacy, Inc., 210 Tenn. 449, 360 S.W.2d 12 [1962], where it was argued that because the employee was killed by her husband in a marital dispute with a knife found o......
-
Anderson v. Save-A-Lot, Ltd.
...personal to the injured employee, inflicted by an acquaintance, can be sufficient to preclude coverage. E.g., White v. Whiteway Pharmacy, 210 Tenn. 449, 360 S.W.2d 12 (1962). When the motives were both personal and employment-related, we resolved the issue in favor of coverage. DeBow v. Fir......
-
Knox v. Batson
...Tenn. 219, 303 S.W.2d 736; J. E. Greene Co. v. Bennett, 207 Tenn. 635, 640-641, 341 S.W.2d 751.' See also, White v. Whiteway Pharmacy, Inc. (1962), 210 Tenn. 449, 360 S.W.2d 12. Upon the facts as found by him, the learned Trial Judge rendered a full Memorandum Opinion, including the review ......
-
Wait v. Travelers Indem. Co. of Illinois
...originating from "inherently private" disputes and imported into the work place are not compensable. See White v. Whiteway Pharm., Inc., 210 Tenn. 449, 360 S.W.2d 12 (1962) (denying compensation where a third party murdered an employee on employer's premises over a domestic dispute). Howeve......