Whitman v. Pilmer, 40741.
Decision Date | 16 December 1931 |
Docket Number | No. 40741.,40741. |
Citation | 214 Iowa 461,239 N.W. 686 |
Parties | WHITMAN v. PILMER ET UX. |
Court | Iowa Supreme Court |
OPINION TEXT STARTS HERE
Appeal from District Court, Polk County; Joseph E. Meyer, Judge.
Action by Lee Whitman, administrator of the estate of Anna Whitman, deceased, against James Pilmer and Mrs. James Pilmer to recover for the death of plaintiff's intestate resulting from defendants' automobile striking her while she was crossing a street. Verdict and judgment for plaintiff. Defendants appeal.
Reversed.
Lehmann, Hurlburt & Hossfeld, of Des Moines, for appellee.
Intestate's residence was on the west side of Seventh street, near the middle of the block. The public sidewalk, which was 6 feet wide, was nearly 17 feet east of the house. East of the sidewalk was a 10-foot, 4-inch parking. The paving east of the curb was 32 feet wide. On the south side of the house was a driveway 9 feet 6 inches in width. The accident occurred about 2:30 in the afternoon of September 1, 1928. At that time the car of decedent's son was parked next to the west curb of the street and north of the driveway. North of this car were parked one or more other cars. The car of Mrs. Lamoreaux was parked against the east curb opposite the Whitman house. Decedent left her house to cross the street and get in the Lamoreaux car. Decedent's son Charles, who was standing in a front door of decedent's home, testified:
Mrs. Pavlik, who was looking out of a window of the next house south, testified:
“My attention was attracted to the street by hearing a lady scream. * * * When I heard the scream and looked Mrs. Whitman was a little over half ways across the street. the east side of the automobile struck her. She was then about even with the driveway. * * * When the automobile came to a stop and the accident was over, Mrs. Whitman was south of me almost even with my car, in front of my house. * * * The driver of the car, after she screamed, threw her hands in the air and screamed again.
Q. Did you see her hands in the air? A. Well, as to that, I wouldn't want to say just to that. * * * I was talking to this woman just as they had taken Mrs. Whitman in and I says, why didn't you run into the pavement, into the curbing, or into some of these cars? She said, all I could do, I saw I was going to hit her, I threw my hands in the air, screamed, closed my eyes and set my brakes. I didn't want to ruin my new Buick car. * * * I saw the car before it hit her. Mrs. Whitman wasn't exactly across the street but she was going across to get in the car. * * * I just couldn't say how far away the car was when I saw it going towards her after I looked up, having heard the scream, because everything was done so quick. * * * The first was a scream. I wouldn't say whether the next time was a screech of a brake or scream. At that time I should judge she was about 2 feet over the middle of the street. * * * The east side of the car hit Mrs. Whitman. * * * I could...
To continue reading
Request your trial-
Lawson v. Fordyce
...property. Wine v. Jones, 183 Iowa 1166, 1170, 162 N.W. 196,168 N.W. 318;Vass v. Martin, 209 Iowa 870, 874, 226 N.W. 920;Whitman v. Pilmer, 214 Iowa 461, 467, 239 N.W. 686;Rolfs v. Mullins, 179 Iowa 1223, 1228, 162 N.W. 783;McMurry v. Guth, 229 Iowa 776, 779, 295 N.W. 133;Orth v. Gregg, 217 ......
- Whitman v. Pilmer