Widaman v. Hubbard
Decision Date | 27 July 1898 |
Docket Number | 772. |
Citation | 88 F. 806 |
Court | U.S. District Court — Southern District of California |
Parties | WIDAMAN v. HUBBARD et al. |
Cheney & Taylor and Anderson & Anderson, for complainant.
Page McCutchen & Eells, E. R. Annable, and Brousseau & Montgomery for defendants.
Complainant sues to enjoin further proceedings in an action entitled 'Anthony G. Hubbard v. New York Life Insurance Company,' pending on the law side of this court, and to have determined certain equitable claims to a fund of $15,000, which said company has paid into court in said action in satisfaction of the liability therein sued on. The material allegations of the bill are these: Complainant, in November, 1896, was, by the superior court of the county of Los Angeles, state of California, appointed assignee in insolvency of one George W. Meade, whose petition in insolvency was filed in the month of October of the same year. The indebtedness of Meade's estate aggregates $30,000, and the only property belonging to said estate is the fund above mentioned. The New York Life Insurance Company is a corporation created under the laws of the state of New York, and on April 22, 1884, for an annual premium of $989.80, issued a tontine policy, numbered 186,405, for $20,000, on the life of said Meade, payable to Anna Meade April 17, 1899, or upon the death of the said George W Meade, should he die before said date. On the 14th day of August, 1894, in consideration of the payment by said Hubbard to said company, at the request of said George W. and Anna Meade, of the quarterly premium then due on said policy of $262.40, said policy was assigned to said Hubbard, and thereafter, on October 29, 1894, said parties entered into the following agreement:
'This article of agreement, made and entered into this 29th day of October, A.D. 1894, between George W. Meade, and his wife, Anna Meade, both of Redlands, San Bernardino county, California, parties of the first part, and Anthony G. Hubbard, of the same place, party of the second part, witnesseth: That, whereas, on the 22d day of April, in the year 1884, a policy of insurance on the life of George W. Meade, one of the parties of the first part, was issued and delivered to the said George W. Meade by the New York Life Insurance Co., of the state of New York, which policy was and is numbered 186,405; and whereas, on the 14th day of August, 1894, the said parties of the first part did assign unto the said party of the second part the said policy of insurance numbered 186,405, which assignment was made to the said party of the second part, and by the said party of the second part accepted as security for certain advances of money then made by the said party of the second part for the benefit of the said parties of the first part, and was also made and accepted, as aforesaid, to secure the said party of the second part for any further advances of money which he, the said party of the second part, may make to the said parties of the first part as the said parties of the first part and the said party of the second part may or should agree upon in the future; and whereas, the said party of the second part is now owner and holder of the mortgage upon certain real property located in the city of Redlands, county of San Bernardino, state of California, now owned by one or both of said parties of the first part, which said real property is described as follows, to wit: ' All of lots 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, and 6 of block 23, as laid down in a map entitled 'Map No. 6' of a part of Redlands Heights, as recorded in the office of the recorder of said county of San Bernardino, state of California, in Book 7 of Maps, at page 40,' and also all that part of Crescent avenue heretofore vacated and not occupied as a public street, lying northwest of and adjoining lot 1, aforementioned, together with 23 shares of the capital stock of the Redlands Heights Water Company; and whereas, the said mortgage so held against the said real property by the said party of the second part was given to secure the payment of a certain promissory note for $6,000, which said promissory note, with accrued and accumulating interest, now remains due and wholly unpaid; and whereas, said Anthony G. Hubbard, said party of the second part, is now the owner and holder of the said policy of insurance on the life of the said George W. Meade: Now, therefore, this article of agreement witnesseth that the said Anthony G. Hubbard shall be and remain the owner of the said policy of insurance hereinbefore referred to, and shall hold the same for the purpose of securing him, the said party of the second part, for any advances of money which he, the said party of the second part, may make to the said party of the first part, or either of them, and it is agreed that the said Anthony G. Hubbard may, at his option, hold the said policy of insurance as collateral security for the said promissory note hereinbefore referred to, and as additional security for the payment of the same, in addition to the mortgage which he now holds against the said real property hereinbefore referred to and described. But it is distinctly understood and agreed that the holding by the said party of the second part of the policy of insurance as further and additional security in connection with the said mortgage shall in no manner be construed as extending the time of payment of the promissory note, to secure the payment of which the said mortgage was given, and is now held by the said party of the second part, the object being to allow the said party of the second part the privilege or option of considering and holding the said policy of insurance as further security for the payment of the said promissory note in the said mortgage described and hereinbefore referred to, according to the terms of the said promissory note, as the same was originally drawn and as the same now exists. In witness whereof, the said parties have hereunto subscribed their names this 29th day of October, 1894.
'(Signed) George W. Meade.
'(Signed) Anna Meade.'
On the day after said agreement was executed, to wit, October 30, 1894, said Hubbard advanced and paid the quarterly premium on said policy for said month of October, and thereafter, on January 17, 1895, advanced and paid the quarterly premium on said policy for said month of January. The promissory note mentioned in the agreement has been discharged. On the 13th day of March, 1895, said insurance company issued another policy of insurance,-- No. 665,889,-- for $15,000, on the life of said George W. Meade, payable to himself; the annual premium on said last-named policy being $562.50. On the 21st day of March, 1895, said Hubbard and Meade entered into the following agreement:
To continue reading
Request your trial-
Pacific Telephone & Telegraph Co. v. Star Pub. Co.
...Mills Co. (C. C.) 31 F. 580, 583; Lamb v. Ewing, 54 F. 269, 273, 4 C. C. A. 320; Broadis v. Broadis (C. C.) 86 F. 951, 954; Widaman v. Hubbard (C. C.) 88 F. 806, 812; Everett v. School Dist. (C. C.) 102 F. 529, 530; Brooks v. Laurent, 98 F. 647, 652, 39 C. C. A. 201; Pac. R. R. of Mo. v. Mo......
-
Gordon v. Ware Nat. Bank
... ... Pythias, 52 N.J.Law, 455, 469, 20 A. 36, 41; Curtiss ... v. Aetna Life Ins. Co., 90 Cal. 245, 27 P. 211, 25 ... Am.St.Rep. 114; Widaman v. Hubbard (C.C.) 88 F. 806, ... 814; Hogue v. Minnesota Packing & Provision Co., 59 ... Minn. 39, 43, 60 N.W. 812; Brown v. Equitable life Assur ... ...
-
Mercer Nat. Bank of Harrodsburg v. White's Ex'r
... ... 570, 86 S.W. 730; Dungan v. Mutual ... Benefit Life Ins. Co., 46 Md. 469; Jones v. N.Y ... Life Ins. Co., 15 Utah 522, 50 P. 620; Widaman v ... Hubbard (C. C.) 88 F. 806; Mandeville v. Kent, ... 88 Hun, 132, 34 N.Y.S. 622; Binkley v. Jarvis, 102 ... Ill.App. 59; Farmers' & T. Bank ... ...
-
Mercer National Bank v. White's Executor
...570, 86 S.W. 730; Dungan v. Mutual Benefit Life Ins. Co., 46 Md. 469; Jones v. N.Y. Life Ins. Co., 15 Utah 522, 50 P. 620; Widaman v. Hubbard (C.C.) 88 F. 806; Mandeville v. Kent, 88 Hun. 132, 34 N.Y.S. 622; Binkley v. Jarvis, 102 Ill. App. 59; Farmers' & T. Bank v. Johnson, 118 Iowa, 282, ......