American Healthcare Management, Inc. v. Director of Revenue
| Decision Date | 09 February 1999 |
| Docket Number | No. 80456,80456 |
| Parties | AMERICAN HEALTHCARE MANAGEMENT, INC., et al., Appellants, v. DIRECTOR OF REVENUE, Respondent. |
| Court | Missouri Supreme Court |
James C. Owen, Chesterfield, James P. Gamble, St. Louis, for Appellants.
Jeremiah W. (Jay) Nixon, Atty. Gen., Evan J. Buchheim, Asst. Atty. Gen., Jefferson City, for Respondent.
American Healthcare Management, Inc., and several other owners and managers of nursing homes (nursing home operators) bring this claim for a refund of sales taxes paid on utility services for the "domestic use" of their nursing home residents. The Administrative Hearing Commission upheld the director of revenue's denials of the sales tax refund claims. We have jurisdiction. Mo. Const. art. V, section 3 and section 18; section 621.189, RSMo 1994. We affirm the commission's decision in part and reverse in part and hold that utility services purchased for nursing home residents are exempt from sales tax for the entire year of 1994.
The residential facilities involved in this case are licensed in whole or in part as nursing homes. 1 During 1994, the nursing home operators paid sales taxes on various utility services. These sales tax payments on various utilities were inconsistent. 2 Consequently, some of these nursing homes were paying sales tax on certain utilities and, at the same time, were exempt from paying sales tax on certain other utilities. In April 1995, the nursing home operators applied to the department of revenue for refunds of those paid sales taxes, contending that the utility services were exempt from sales tax under the domestic use exemption pursuant to section 144.030.2(23). The director of revenue denied their applications on the ground that their businesses operated as health care facilities.
On January 18, 1996, Delmar Gardens Enterprise, Inc., d/b/a Delmar Gardens of Chesterfield, filed a complaint with the commission challenging the director's denial of its claim for the sales tax refund. On January 19, 1996, American Healthcare Management, Inc., and other appellants filed a similar complaint challenging the director's decision as to their sales tax refund claims. The cases were consolidated. Pursuant to a joint motion by the parties on July 18, 1996, the commission ordered that the claims of other petitioners be held in abeyance except the claims of American Healthcare Management, Inc., (in regard to Oak Forest North Nursing Home), McKnight Place Partnership I, L.L.P.; R. Development, Inc.; Reliant Care Four Seasons, L.L.C.; and Reliance Care Heritage, L.L.C. The claims held in abeyance apparently involve the same issue.
The commission entered its findings of fact and conclusions of law, holding that all of the appellants' facilities were residential and that none of the appellants were entitled to a refund for periods prior to August 28, 1994. The commission also concluded that McKnight Place Partnership used 95 percent of its floor space for residential purposes and that it was entitled to a refund of 95 percent of taxes paid from August 28, 1994, through December 31, 1994. The commission further determined that the remaining appellant nursing home operators were not entitled to any refund for taxes paid from August 28, 1994, because they were not apartments or condominiums and had not presented an appropriate means of allocating the utilities used by the individual residents. The nursing home operators petition this Court to review the commission's findings and conclusions.
Nursing Homes as "Residential Apartments"
The nursing home operators argue that the commission erred when it ruled that the nursing homes were not "residential apartments" under section 144.030.2(23)(a) and, consequently, not entitled to the domestic use exemption. Section 144.030.2(23) was amended effective August 28, 1994, providing a sales tax exemption for:
all sales of metered water service, electricity, electrical current, natural, artificial or propane gas, wood, coal or home heating oil for domestic use and in any city not within a county, all sales of metered or unmetered water service for domestic use;
(a) "Domestic Use" means that portion of metered water service, electricity, electrical current, natural, artificial or propane gas, wood, coal or home heating oil for domestic use and in any city not within a county, metered or unmetered water service, which an individual occupant of a residential premise uses for nonbusiness, noncommercial or nonindustrial purposes. Utility service through a single or master meter for residential apartments or condominiums, including service for common areas and facilities and vacant units, shall be deemed to be for domestic use. Each seller shall establish and maintain a system whereby individual purchases are determined as exempt or nonexempt;....
Section 144.030.2(23)(c) provides that individuals making purchases on behalf of occupants of residential apartments or condominiums shall have standing to apply to the director of revenue for credit or refund.
The commission correctly decided that the nursing homes are residential facilities but erred in ruling that the nursing homes are not residential apartments. The statute does not define "residential apartments." The rules on construing revenue laws are in equipoise in this case. Statutes imposing taxes are to be construed against the taxing authority and in favor of the taxpayer. Columbia Athletic Club v. Director of Revenue, 961 S.W.2d 806, 809 (Mo. banc 1998). However, statutes creating exemptions from taxation are strictly construed against the taxpayer. Hyde Park Housing Partnership v. Director of Revenue, 850 S.W.2d 82, 84 (Mo. banc 1993). In Hyde Park this Court stated: "[t]he primary rule of statutory construction is to ascertain the intent of the lawmakers by construing words used in the statute in their plain and ordinary meaning." Id. Absent statutory definition, words used in statutes are given their plain and ordinary meaning with help, as needed, from the dictionary. Columbia Athletic Club, supra at 809. Webster's Third New International Dictionary (1993) defines an apartment as "a room or a set of rooms used as a dwelling and located in a private house, a hotel, or a building containing only such rooms or suites with necessary passageways and hallways," or more simply, "a building made up of individual dwelling units." An apartment building or apartment house is "[a] building containing a number of units and usually having conveniences (as heat and elevators) in common." Id.
Nursing homes are residential facilities and are apartments under the common dictionary definition. These nursing homes have a number of dwelling units, and they usually have common conveniences, including heat and elevators. The nursing home residents, like those in apartments or condominiums, live in these units and use these utilities for domestic purposes.
Likewise, the commission's decision granted a sales tax exemption to those portions of a complex designed for senior citizens that was residential only and denied the exemption for those areas of the facility where residents receive some level of nursing care. The economic reality is that sales taxes on utilities are ultimately passed on to the residents. It hardly makes sense to impose the tax burden on those who are receiving some level of direct care while reserving the exemption for those who are less in need of care. We do not think that the legislature intended this result. Nursing homes are special homes for their residents. The residents could have leased regular apartments but, due to their special needs, they have found themselves in these specialized facilities to have health and other care services provided by these nursing homes. Similarly these residents could have opted to stay in their homes and receive home health care services, without having their utilities subject to sales tax. Nothing about the care that is provided detracts from the notion that these nursing homes are residential apartments. As such, they are entitled to the sales tax exemption.
Moreover, as noted above, the current method of imposing and exempting nursing homes from payments of sales taxes on various utilities is inconsistent. The Gatesworth pays sales tax on its gas and water services but it...
To continue reading
Request your trial
-
In re Danzig, BAP No. 98-6096EM.
...of the lawmakers by construing words used in the statute in their plain and ordinary meaning." American Healthcare Management, Inc. v. Director of Revenue, 984 S.W.2d 496, 498 (Mo.1999) (quoting Hyde Park Housing Partnership v. Director of Revenue, 850 S.W.2d 82, 84 (Mo.1993)) (internal quo......
-
Mansfield v. Horner
...words used in statutes are given their plain and ordinary meaning with help, as needed, from the dictionary.” Am. Healthcare Mgmt., Inc. v. Dir. of Revenue, 984 S.W.2d 496, 498 (Mo. banc 1999). However, where the legislature has defined a term in one statute, its failure to do so in another......
-
Bowers v. Bowers
...v. White, 293 S.W.3d at 1, 10 n.6 (Mo. App. W.D. 2009) (citing BLACK'S LAW DICTIONARY (8th ed. 2004)); see also Am. Healthcare Mgmt., Inc. v. Dir. of Revenue, 984 S.W.2d 496, 498 (Mo. banc 1998) ("Absent statutory definition, words used in statutes are given their plain and ordinary meaning......
-
Dean Machinery Co. v. Union Bank
...State, Mo. Dep't of Soc. Servs. v Brookside Nursing Center, Inc., 50 S.W.3d 273, 276 (Mo. banc 2001) (citing Am. Healthcare Mgmt., Inc. v. Dir. of Revenue, 984 S.W.2d 496, 498 (Mo. banc 1999)). "Explicitly" is defined as "fully and clearly expressed or demonstrated; leaving nothing merely i......