Bass v. Cuyler
| Citation | 36 Pa.Cmwlth. 74,387 A.2d 964 |
| Parties | Shirley Lillian BASS, Administratrix of the Estate of Stanley Bass, Deceased, Plaintiff, v. Julius CUYLER, Superintendent of Graterford Prison, et al., Defendants. |
| Decision Date | 13 June 1978 |
| Court | Pennsylvania Commonwealth Court |
M. Faith Angell, Stanley I. Slipakoff, Michael von Moschzisker, Philadelphia, for plaintiff.
Robert A. Rovner, Feasterville, for defendants.
Before ROGERS, BLATT and DiSALLE, JJ.
Shirley L. Bass (plaintiff) filed a complaint in trespass in the Court of Common Pleas of Montgomery County against Julius Cuyler, Superintendent of the Graterford State Correctional Institution (Graterford), William Robinson, Commissioner of the Commonwealth's Bureau of Correction, Larry Reid, Director of Treatment at Graterford, and John Doe, identified only as a "state employee" of Graterford (defendants) alleging that they were negligent in permitting a Graterford inmate to have a weekend furlough during which time he killed the plaintiff's husband. The defendants filed preliminary objections to the complaint in the court below, questioning that court's jurisdiction, and the action was subsequently transferred to this Court. Before us are preliminary objections raising the defense of immunity from suit. 1
In determining the issue of immunity, we must first examine whether or not each of the named defendants is an officer of the Commonwealth over whom this Court has jurisdiction. Schroeck v. Pennsylvania State Police, 26 Pa.Cmwlth. 41, 362 A.2d 486 (1976). If a defendant is found to be an officer, we have held that he or she is necessarily entitled to absolute immunity as a high public official. Fischer v. Kassab, 32 Pa.Cmwlth. 581, 380 A.2d 926 (1977).
We have previously examined the duties of the Commonwealth's Commissioner of the Bureau of Correction and found him to be an officer entitled to absolute immunity. Staley v. Commonwealth, 33 Pa.Cmwlth. 22, 380 A.2d 515 (1977). We will, therefore, sustain the preliminary objections of defendant William Robinson and dismiss the complaint as to him.
We have also held that the superintendent (sometimes called "warden") of a state correctional institution is not charged with the kind of statewide policy-making responsibility required for him to be considered an officer for jurisdictional purposes. Staley v. Commonwealth, supra. Consequently, we have no jurisdiction to rule on the question of Julius Cuyler's immunity from suit, and we must transfer the action against him back to the Court of Common Pleas of Montgomery County for that court's determination of the issue.
With respect to the other two Graterford employees, they are clearly not officers and we, therefore, lack jurisdiction over them. The actions brought against them must also be transferred back to the lower court.
AND, NOW, this 13th day of June, 1978, the preliminary objections of William Robinson are hereby sustained and as to him the plaintiff's complaint is dismissed.
With respect to the other three defendants, the remaining causes of action are hereby transferred to the Court of Common Pleas of Montgomery...
To continue reading
Request your trial
-
Fraisar v. Gillis
...of a prison is not an "officer" of the state for purposes of invoking this Court's original jurisdiction. Bass v. Cuyler, 36 Pa.Cmwlth. 74, 387 A.2d 964, 965 (1978); see Section 761 of the Judicial Code, 42 Pa.C.S. § 2. Our scope of review of a trial court's decision is limited to determini......
-
Balshy v. Rank
...Pleas for trial. See, Wallace v. Commonwealth, Dept. of Public Welfare, 32 Pa.Commw. 615, 380 A.2d 930 (1977) and Bass v. Cuyler, 36 Pa.Commw.Ct. 74, 387 A.2d 964 (1978). But see Freach v. Commonwealth, 471 Pa. 558, 370 A.2d 1163 (1977) (where Section 603 of the Mental Health and Mental Ret......
-
Borough of Pottstown v. Pennsylvania Labor Relations Bd.
...is absolutely immune from suit. In that context, a Pottstown assistant borough fire chief would not be one. See Bass v. Cuyler, 36 Pa.Cmwlth. 74, 387 A.2d 964 (1979); Staley v. Commonwealth, 33 Pa.Cmwlth. 22, 380 A.2d 515 ...
-
Madden v. Jeffes
...v. Jeffes, 71 Pa. Commonwealth Ct. 68, 453 A.2d 1092 (1983), is an employee rather than an officer. Accord Bass v. Cuyler, 36 Pa. Commonwealth Ct. 74, 387 A.2d 964 (1978). However, the claim against Superintendent Petsock is ancillary to the claims against Commonwealth parties and, therefor......