Board of Com'rs of Walton County v. Department of Public Health, 26981
| Citation | 190 S.E.2d 39,229 Ga. 173 |
| Decision Date | 19 May 1972 |
| Docket Number | No. 26981,26981 |
| Parties | BOARD OF COMMISSIONERS OF WALTON COUNTY v. DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC HEALTH et al. |
| Court | Supreme Court of Georgia |
Sorrells, Hearn & Childers, George J. Hearn, III, William R. Childers, Jr., Monroe, for appellant.
H. O. Godwin, Social Circle, William L. Preston, C. Thomas Allgood, Jr., Monroe, Arthur K. Bolton, Atty. Gen., Harold N. Hill, Jr., Executive Asst. Atty. Gen., Alfred L. Evans, Jr., Carl C. Jones, III, Asst. Attys. Gen., Atlanta, for appellees.
Syllabus Opinion by the Court
The State of Georgia, by and through the Georgia Department of Public Health, filed a complaint in the Superior Court of Walton County against the City of Social Circle seeking a temporary and permanent injunction against the city to restrain the maintenance and operation by the city of a garbage dump in violation of the Georgia Department of Public Health's rules and regulations. The trial court issued a rule nisi commanding the defendant to show cause on October 23, 1971, why the demands of the plaintiff's complaint should not be granted. At the same time the court issued an ex parte restraining order restraining the defendant 'from continuing to fail to act in accordance with the Georgia Department of Public Health's rules and regulations and from continuing to operate and amintain a public nuisance.' The hearing on the temporary injunction was continued until October 30th, and, on that date, the City of Social Circle filed its answer, together with a motion that the Board of Commissioners of Walton County, Georgia, be made a party to the proceeding. On that motion, the trial court issued a rule nisi commanding it to show cause before the court on the 10th day of November, 1971, why the board should not be made a party defendant in the case. That order was served on the chairman of the board on the same day, to wit, October 30, 1971. On November 10, 1971, when the case came on to be heard, the trial court, after hearing evidence and argument of counsel, passed an order making the Commissioners of Roads and Revenues of Walton County a party defendant. Thereafter, a judgment temporarily enjoining the defendants from continuing to violate the public health regulations of the State of Georgia in the operation and maintenance of the garbage demp in question located within the City of Social Circle was entered. As a part of the restraining order, the court found 'that a correction of the situation requiring theinjunction can be effected by the use of county equipment and labor to construct a ditch which may be used as a land fill operation, and that this, insofar as the county is concerned, will constitute a compliance with the injunction which the court is issuing.' The board of commissioners appealed from the judgment making it a party defendant in the case and from the judgment granting an interlocutory injunction. The grounds of enumerated error are that the court erred in granting the motion of appellee, the City of Social Circle, to add an additional party; in denying appellant's motion to dismiss the motion to add an additional party; in granting the interlocutory injunction, and, in thereby requiring the Walton County Board of Commissioners to do a mandatory act. The City of Social Circle, as appellee, has filed in this court a motion to dismiss the appeal on the ground that the questions presented thereby are moot in that the county has complied with the order of the court by constructing the ditch referred to in the portion of the order quoted above. This motion to dismiss is supported by an affidavit of the Mayor of the City of Social Circle. The county has filed a supplemental brief in opposition to the motion to dismiss and supports its position by an affidavit of the Chairman of the Board of Commissioners of Walton County. In this affidavit, the chairman does not deny that the ditch has been constructed in accordance with the order of the court. Held:
1. The trial court did not err in ordering the Board of Commissioners of Walton County to be made a party defendant in the case. Code Ann. § 81A-119(b).
2. Appellant urges that the construction of the ditch in accordance with the order should not render the case moot because appellant is being and will be urged by other municipalities located within the bounds of Walton County to perform the same service for those cities and that without direction from this court the county is faced with the dilemma of complying with such requests from other cities on the one hand or being faced with potential personal liability and 'infamy' on the other hand. It is further urged that the county is not authorized to levy taxes for this purpose, has levied no taxes and, therefore, can make no expenditure of funds for the purpose of constructing ditches on municipal land fills. The sole question presented by the appeal and by the enumeration of errors on the final judgment is whether the court erred in granting the injunctive order appealed from. No such...
To continue reading
Request your trial
-
I.B., In Interest of
...have no authority to render an advisory opinion. See Cheeks, supra at 689, 425 S.E.2d 278; Bd. of Commrs. of Walton County v. Dept. of Public Health, 229 Ga. 173, 175-176(2), 190 S.E.2d 39 (1972); Froelich, supra at 649, 437 S.E.2d 358. 6 Neither can the trial court merely advise I.B.'s fat......
-
Sons of Confederate Veterans v. Henry Cnty. Bd. of Comm'rs
...in a declaratory judgment action is the court permitted to render an advisory opinion."); Bd. of Commrs. of Walton County v. Dept. of Public Health , 229 Ga. 173, 175-176 (2), 190 S.E.2d 39 (1972) ("In raising those questions on appeal, the appellant seeks to secure the opinion of this cour......
-
Sons of Confederate Veterans v. Henry Cnty. Bd. of Comm'rs
... ... HENRY COUNTY BOARD OF COMMISSIONERS. HUMPHRIES v. NEWTON ... Department of Natural Resources v. Center for a Sustainable ... by Roberts v. Unison Behav. Health , 312 Ga. 438 (863 ... S.E.2d 99) (2021); ... public expense) monuments that celebrate the Confederacy ... opinion"); Bd. of Commrs. of Walton Cnty. v. Dept ... of Public Health , 229 ... ...
-
Froelich v. State
...legal questions that have not arisen but which [petitioners] fear may arise at a future date. Board of Commrs. of Walton County v. Dept. of Public Health, 229 Ga. 173(2) (190 SE2d 39) (1972)." Cheeks v. Miller, 262 Ga. 687, 689, 425 S.E.2d 278. Alternatively, petitioners appear to concede t......