Cotton States Mut. Ins. Co. v. Keefe
Decision Date | 07 April 1960 |
Docket Number | No. 20775,20775 |
Citation | 215 Ga. 830,113 S.E.2d 774 |
Parties | COTTON STATES MUTUAL INSURANCE COMPANY v. Wallace A. KEEFE, Sr. |
Court | Georgia Supreme Court |
Syllabus by the Court
1. Ware County constitutes one school district and, as such, is such a body corporate or legal entity that it comes within the purview of the act of 1955 (Ga.L.1955, p. 448; Code, Ann., § 56-1013), and the Board of Education of Ware County had authority to obtain liability insurance; and under the provisions of the act of 1955 (supra), the school district was subject to direct action for damages by reason of injury to person or property caused by the negligent operation of its school buses covered by insurance. The Court of Appeals erred in holding that the said act was not applicable.
2. There is nothing either in the act of 1949 (Ga.L.1949, p. 1155; Code, Ann., § 32-429) or the act of 1955 (supra) as to the type or kind of insurance which the boards of education are required to procure. There are no provisions in the act of 1949 (supra) which require the county boards of education to obtain policies of insurance that permit a direct action by the person injured against the insurance company; and the ruling of the Court of Appeals that the provision in the policy of insurance under consideration, that the company would be liable only after legal liability had been established by judgment or agreement, contravenes the provisions of the act of 1949 (supra), was erroneous.
Hull, Willingham, Towill & Norman, Augusta, Memory, Barnes & Memory, Waycross, Kenyon, Kenyon & Gunter, Gainesville, for plaintiff in error.
Blount & Gibson, Waycross, for defendant in error.
Dunaway, Embry & Shelfer, Atlanta, for party at interest.
The act of 1949 (Ga.L.1949, p. 1155; Code, Ann., §§ 32-429, 32-431). (a) Authorized and required county school boards operating school buses 'to cause policies of insurance to be issued insuring the school children riding therein to and from school against bodily injury or death at any time therefrom resulting from an accident or collision in which said buses are involved,' the amount of insurance being left in the discretion of the board; and (b) authorized such school boards to cause a provision to be inserted in said policies 'insuring the members of the general public against personal injury or death or damage to property resulting from the negligent operation of said buses.' It was provided that nothing in the act should be construed as imposing liability upon the school board on account of such accidents; and that the insurance company issuing a policy containing a provision insuring the general public 'shall be estopped to deny its liability thereunder on account of the nonliability of said board.'
Under the act of 1955 (Ga.L.1955, p. 448; Code, Ann., § 56-1013), a county or any political subdivision of this State was authorized to procure and provide insurance to cover liability for damages on account of bodily injuries or death resulting therefrom to any person or for damages to property of any person, or both, arising by reason of the ownership, maintenance, operation, or use of any motor vehicle by the county or any other political subdivision of this State under its management, control or supervision, whether a governmental undertaking or not, and to pay premiums therefor.
Section 2 of this act (Ga.L.1955, pp. 448, 449; Code, Ann., § 56-1014) provided that when a county or political subdivision shall purchase such insurance its governmental immunity for the negligence of its agents, employees, and servants shall be waived to the extent of the amount of insurance purchased and neither the political subdivision nor the insuring company
On September 3, 1957, Cotton States Mutual Insurance Company (hereinafter referred to as the insurance company) issued to the Ware County Board of Education a policy of insurance for a period ending June 3, 1958, the policy issued being a combined comprehensive liability policy covering the operation of school buses by the Ware County Board of Education. The policy coverage as to the general public, as set out in Coverages A and B of the Insuring Agreements in the policy, was: As to actions against the company under Coverages A and B, the policy provided:
In March, 1957, Wallace A. Keefe, Sr., filed his suit against the insurance company, alleging that he sustained injuries to his person and property by reason of the negligent operation of a school bus owned by the Ware County Board of Education, and sought to recover damages from the insurance company, it being alleged that it was liable to the plaintiff under the terms of the policy, a copy of the policy being attached to the petition. The insurance company filed its general demurrers, in which it asserted: (a) it was not liable to the plaintiff either in tort or contract, and (b) the plaintiff is not a beneficiary under the policy and has no right of action against the company. The general demurrers were overruled and this ruling was affirmed by the Court of Appeals. Cotton States Mutual Insurance Co. v. Keefe, 100 Ga.App. 715, 112 S.E.2d 435.
That court held that, under the provisions of the act of 1949 (Ga.L.1949, p. 1155) (a) Insurance companies issuing policies of liability insurance to school boards are subject to direct suit by a member of the general public as the result of the negligent operation of school buses insured; (b) a provision in the policy that the company shall not be subject to suit until the obligation of the insured shall have been determined by judgment against the insured or by written agreement of the insured, the claimant, and the company was void as contravening the provisions of the act of 1949 (supra); and (c) the act of 1955 (Ga.L.1955, p. 448; Code, Ann. § 56-1013) does not apply to county school boards, such boards not being political subdivisions of the State.
Assigning error on these rulings, the insurance company filed its application for the writ of certiorari, which we granted.
1. The act of 1955 (supra) authorizes a county or any political subdivision of the State to purchase insurance to cover liability for...
To continue reading
Request your trial-
Sheley v. Board of Public Ed. for City of Savannah and Chatham County
...provisions, provide for a payment of school taxes for purposes other than educational. This was recognized in Cotton States Mutual Ins. Co. v. Keefe, 215 Ga. 830, 113 S.E.2d 774. Nothing that we have been able to find, in the statutes or in the Constitution, or in the case law of this state......
-
Schaefer v. Mayor and Council of City of Athens
...suits against a political subdivision which has obtained liability insurance pursuant to Code Ann. § 32-429, Cotton States Mutual Ins. Co. v. Keefe, 215 Ga. 830, 113 S.E.2d 774, or under Code Ann. § 56-2437 which establishes a public policy against it by specifically prohibiting reference t......
-
Plantation Pipe Line Co. v. City of Bremen
...Consolidated School District, 186 Ga. 541, 198 S.E. 225; Towns v. Suttles, 208 Ga. 838, 840, 69 S.E.2d 742; Cotton States Mutual Insurance Co. v. Keefe, 215 Ga. 830, 113 S.E.2d 774. Art. VII, Sec. V, Par. I of the Constitution of 1945 provides: 'Each county, exclusive of any independent sch......
-
Amphitheater Unified School Dist. No. 10 v. Harte, 14806
...P.2d 1299 (1974); Watts v. Double Oak Independent School District, 377 S.W.2d 779 (Tex.Civ.App.1964); Cotton States Mutual Insurance Co. v. Keefe, 215 Ga. 830, 113 S.E.2d 774 (1960); Skelly v. Westminster School District of Orange County, 103 Cal. 652, 37 P. 643 (1894); 78 C.J.S. Schools an......