Geele v. State
Decision Date | 12 June 1947 |
Docket Number | 15814. |
Citation | 43 S.E.2d 254,202 Ga. 381 |
Parties | GEELE et al. v. STATE. |
Court | Georgia Supreme Court |
Syllabus by the Court.
The provisions of the act approved August 15, 1910, Ga.L.1910 pp. 88, 89, requiring hotels and inns three stories in height and over to provide fire escapes on the outside of such buildings, and providing that the violation thereof shall be a misdemeanor, and that the act shall include only hotels and inns charging patrons or guests $2 per day and more, offends the equal-protection provision of the State and Federal Constitutions, in that the classification is arbitrary, since it is based upon the amount charged the guests and bears no conceivable relation to the purpose of the law, which is the protection of the guests against the danger of fire. The court erred in overruling the demurrer to the indictment based upon this law, which challenged the act upon the ground that it is unconstitutional, in that it offends the equal-protection clause of the State and Federal Constitutions.
An indictment in Fulton Superior Court against A. F. Geele, Sr. A. F. Geele, Jr., and R. E. O'Connell charged the defendants with involuntary manslaughter in the following manner:
The defendants jointly demurred to the indictment, the demurrer being as follows:
The judgment overruling the demurrer was as follows: 'The within demurrers to the indictment in the above-stated case coming on for hearing, after argument and consideration, it is considered, ordered and adjudged that the general and special demurrers be and are hereby overruled on each and every ground.' (Citing cases) The exception here is to the judgment overruling the demurrer.
Smith, Kilpatrick, Cody, Rogers & McClatchey, and E. D. Smith, Jr., all of Atlanta, for plaintiffs in error.
E. E. Andrews and Paul Webb, Sols.Gen., and J. Walter Le Craw, all of Atlanta, for defendant in error.
DUCKWORTH, Presiding Justice (after stating the foregoing facts).
The Constitutional question here presented is clearly made and calls for a forthright decision. The statute upon which the constitutional attacks are made is section 4, 5, and 6 of the act of 1910, Ga.L.1910, pp. 88, 89. The ground of attack is that the statute is discriminatory against hotels and inns charging their guests $2 and more, to which the law applies, and in favor of hotels and inns charging their guests less than $2, which are exempt from the requirement of the law that fire escapes on the outside be provided, and that a failure to conform to this requirement is a misdemeanor.
The applicable rule of law, which is the recognized standard by which classification by legislation must be tested, may be stated succinctly as follows. The basis for classification must...
To continue reading
Request your trial-
Howard v. State, 18730
...made and the law is made applicable alike to all members of that class. Arthur v. State, 146 Ga. 827, 92 S.E. 637; Geele v. State, 202 Ga. 381, 43 S.E.2d 254, 172 A.L.R. 196. Such a classification, however, must have a basis that bears a direct relationship to the object and purpose of the ......
-
Citizens and Southern Nat. Bank v. Mann, 30128
...Coy v. Linder, 183 Ga. 583, 189 S.E. 26; Carmichael v. Atlanta Gas-Light Co., 185 Ga. 34, 193 S.E. 896; Geele v. State, 202 Ga. 381, 43 S.E.2d 254, 172 A.L.R. 196; Ledger-Enquirer Co. v. Brown, 213 Ga. 538, 100 S.E.2d 166; Simpson v. State, 218 Ga. 337, 127 S.E.2d 907. 'A statutory discrimi......
-
Turner v. Prigmore
... ... application of a foreign guardian, to order the sale, for the ... purpose of reinvestment in United States bonds, of lands in ... this State belonging to his wards, and upon a hearing the ... judge enters an order for such sale, jurisdiction is properly ... retained for the purpose of ... ...
-
Ford Motor Co. v. Abercrombie
...art. 7, sec. 1, par. 3, Code, Ann., § 2-5403, Ga.L.1945, p. 58; Wright v. Fulton County, 169 Ga. 354, 150 S.E. 262; Geele v. State, 202 Ga. 381, 43 S.E.2d 254, 172 A.L.R. 196. Counsel for the claimants also quote in their brief from Phillips, Inc., v. Walling, 324 U.S. 490, 65 S.Ct. 807, 80......
-
State-mandated Occupational Licenses, Harmful or Helpful? a Look at the Due Process and Equal Protection Principles Surrounding the Constitutionality of Occupational Licensing Regulations
...Atlanta v. Watson, 267 Ga. 185, 475 S.E.2d 896 (1996).103. 190 Ga. 613, 10 S.E.2d 58 (1940).104. Id. at 616, 10 S.E.2d at 60.105. Id.106. 202 Ga. 381, 43 S.E.2d 254 (1947). 107. Id. at 387-88, 43 s.e.2d at 258. The statute required hotels and inns to maintain proper fire escapes unless they......