Gilbert Builders, Inc. v. Community Bank of DePere
| Decision Date | 16 June 1987 |
| Docket Number | No. C4-86-1830,C4-86-1830 |
| Citation | 407 N.W.2d 706 |
| Parties | GILBERT BUILDERS, INC., Appellant, v. COMMUNITY BANK OF DEPERE, Respondent, Brownstone Partnership, et al., Defendants, Ryan Air Conditioning, Inc., Metroquip, Inc., Electric Service Company of Minneapolis, Inc., Hayes Contractors, Inc., Daryl Burnham, Acoustical Floors, Inc., Appellants, Victor Carlson & Sons, Inc., Defendant, Warren Swanson, d/b/a Swanson Brothers Drywall, Appellant. |
| Court | Minnesota Court of Appeals |
Syllabus by the Court
Mortgagee of a vendee's interest in a contract for deed extinguished its mortgage by purchasing the vendor's interest and cancelling the mortgagor-vendee's contract.
Peter C. Halls, Hart, Bruner, O'Brien & Thornton, P.A., Minneapolis, for Gilbert Builders, Inc.
Stephen J. Guy, Bernet & Guy, St. Paul, for Community Bank of DePere.
Craig M. Mertz, Minneapolis, for Ryan Air Conditioning, Inc.
Peter J. Timmons, Moss & Barnett, Minneapolis, for Metroquip, Inc.
Leland J. Frankman, Minneapolis, for Electric Service Co.
R. Jeffrey McLeod, R. Jeffrey McLeod, P.A., Golden Valley, for Hayes Contractors, Inc.
Malcolm MacGregor, Smith, Persian, MacGregor & Thompson, Minneapolis, for Acoustical Floors, Inc.
Michael T. Hoekstra, Wayzata, for Swanson.
John M. Koneck, Fredrikson & Byron, Minneapolis, representing Gordon Millwork Co.
Heard, considered and decided by PARKER, P.J., and SEDGWICK and LANSING, JJ.
Plaintiffs, who have mechanics' liens against the property located at 1628 Elliott Avenue in Minneapolis, brought an action to foreclose the liens. They moved for a summary judgment determining that the bank's mortgage, which extended only to the vendee's interest, was extinguished when the bank purchased the property from the contract vendor and cancelled the vendee's interest. The trial court denied the lien claimants' motion and entered summary judgment for the bank, holding that the bank's mortgage was not extinguished and was superior to the mechanics' liens. The lien claimants appeal. We reverse and remand.
On January 9, 1982, Brownstone Partnership purchased the Elliott Avenue property from Stephen Blumberg on a contract for deed in the amount of $106,000 and assumed a $44,000 mortgage. The contract for deed provided for a balloon payment on January 9, 1983. On July 2, 1982, Brownstone mortgaged its vendee's interest in the property to the Community Bank of DePere as security for a $250,000 loan.
Brownstone entered into a construction contract with Gilbert Builders to renovate the large brownstone structure located on the property. Gilbert, its suppliers and subcontractors furnished materials and labor amounting to over $490,000, but received payment for only $130,942. They filed mechanics' liens on the property for the remaining amount.
Brownstone failed to make its January 9, 1983, balloon payment and the bank was notified of Brownstone's default on March 23, 1983. On April 22, 1983, the bank paid the contract for deed balance to Blumberg in exchange for a warranty deed and an assignment of his vendor's interest.
The bank served notice of cancellation of the contract for deed on Brownstone, Gilbert and all subcontractors who had filed mechanics' liens after June 1983. The bank completed the cancellation of the contract in accordance with Minnesota law. The bank did not foreclose the mortgage; instead, it sued Brownstone and its two general partners, Shirley Martinek-Maun and S. Kris Bandel, on the note underlying the mortgage. The full amount of the mortgage note, all interest and attorney's fees against Brownstone and Martinek-Maun were reduced to judgment.
Instead of entering judgment against Bandel, the bank, on December 16, 1983, sold the property on a contract for deed to Bandel individually and to Sancher Elliot, a Minnesota general partnership formed by Bandel. The contract was in the amount of $869,945: $50,000 payable upon execution of the contract, $519,545 payable by express assumption of the accumulated lien obligations, and the remaining $300,000 financed at 16 percent.
On July 11, 1983, the lien claimants brought this foreclosure action. In response to motions for summary judgment, the trial court entered judgment for the bank, holding that its mortgage on the vendee's interest in the contract for deed was not extinguished by the cancellation of the contract and the mortgage was superior to the mechanics' liens. The lien claimants appeal.
Is a mortgage on a contract vendee's equitable title extinguished when the mortgagee acquires the vendor's rights and cancels the contract for deed?
It is long-standing law in Minnesota that once statutory notice has been served and cancellation effected, all rights between the parties under a contract for deed are terminated. Gatz v. Frank M. Langenfeld & Sons Construction, Inc., 356 N.W.2d 716, 718 (Minn.Ct.App.1984) (citing Zirinsky v. Sheehan, 413 F.2d 481, 484 (8th Cir.1969), cert. denied, 369 U.S. 1059, 90 S.Ct. 754, 24 L.Ed.2d 753 (1970); West v. Walker, 181 Minn. 169, 171, 231 N.W. 826, 827 (1930); Olson v. Northern Pacific Railway Co., 126 Minn. 229, 230-31, 148 N.W. 67, 68 (1914)). Although the issue in the present case is not between the parties to the original contract, the basic principles underlying installment land contracts are still applicable.
Under a contract for deed for the purchase of real estate, the vendee is the equitable owner of the property, but the vendor retains legal title as security for the purchase price of the property. The vendee's equitable interest--in this case Brownstone's interest under the contract from Blumberg--is mortgageable. See Stannard v. Marboe, 159 Minn. 119, 120, 198 N.W. 127 (1924) (); see also G. Nelson and D. Whitman, Real Estate Finance Law Sec. 3.35, at 127 (2d ed. 1985). The mortgagee does not have a lien on the real property, but the mortgage extends only to the equitable interest held by the mortgagor. See Rosendahl v. Mudbaden Sulphur Springs Co., 144 Minn. 361, 362-63, 175 N.W. 609 (1919). The mortgage is enforceable only so long as the contract for deed is kept in force.
A mortgage lien on a vendee's interest is extinguished with the cancellation of the contract for deed. Peterson v. Siebrecht, 188 Minn. 272, 276-77, 247 N.W. 6, 7 (1933); Farmers' & Merchant's State Bank of Thief River Falls v. Stageberg, 161 Minn. 413, 415, 201 N.W. 612, 613 (1925); see also Schrunk v. Andres, 221 Minn. 465, 22 N.W.2d 548 (1946) (); Vista Management, Ltd. v. Cooper, 81 Or.App. 660, 726 P.2d 974 (1986) (); Estate of Brewer v. Iota Delta Chapter, 298 Or. 383, 692 P.2d 597 (1984) (); Wiscombe v. Lockhart Co., 608 P.2d 236 (Utah 1980); Sheehan v. McKinstry, 105 Or. 473, 210 P. 167 (1922).
In Stageberg the court held that the lien of a judgment creditor, in the absence of estoppel or controlling equity, does not attach to the naked legal title of which the judgment debtor has no beneficial interest. When the vendee's interest in property is divested by the cancellation of the contract, the lien terminates as well. Stageberg, 161 Minn. at 415, 201 N.W. at 612-13.
Similarly, the court in Siebrecht held that when a vendee's interest in real property under a contract for deed is cancelled by statutory notice for default in payment, a judgment creditor of the vendee, whose judgment is a lien upon the...
To continue reading
Request your trial
-
Homer v. Guzulaitis
...correct statement of Minnesota law, see Hollywood Dairy, Inc. v. Timmer (1987), Minn.App., 411 N.W.2d 258; Gilbert Bldrs. v. Community Bank of DePere (1987), Minn.App., 407 N.W.2d 706, pet. for rev. denied, but it is not well taken here. As will be remembered from our recitation of the fact......
-
Nelson v. Nelson
...holds the title in trust for the vendee. Summers, 167 Minn. at 455, 209 N.W. at 323-24. See also Gilbert Builders, Inc. v. Community Bank of DePere, 407 N.W.2d 706, 708 (Minn.Ct.App.1987), pet. for rev. denied (Minn. Aug. 19, Appellant next argues that even if he was the owner of the land a......
-
In re Ehrich
...493, 507, 18 N.W.2d 442, 449-50 (1945), aff'd, 327 U.S. 558, 66 S.Ct. 749, 90 L.Ed. 851 (1946); Gilbert Builders, Inc. v. Community Bank of DePere, 407 N.W.2d 706, 708 (Minn.App.1987), rev. den. (Minn. August 19, 1987); Friberg v. Fagen, 404 N.W.2d 400, 403-04 (Minn.App.1987). Under the con......
-
Rudnitski v. Seely, C0-89-43
...deed, the vendee has equitable title, but the vendor retains legal title until full payment. See Gilbert Builders, Inc. v. Community Bank of DePere, 407 N.W.2d 706, 708 (Minn.Ct.App.1987), pet. for rev. denied (Minn. Aug. 19, 1987). Thus, a vendor retains the right to protect the property, ......