Guardianship of Bohac, In re
| Decision Date | 29 February 1980 |
| Docket Number | No. 79-1022,79-1022 |
| Citation | 380 So.2d 550 |
| Parties | In re the GUARDIANSHIP OF Helen F. BOHAC, Incompetent. |
| Court | Florida District Court of Appeals |
William H. Grace of Allen, Knudsen, Swartz, DeBoest, Rhoads & Edwards, P. A., Fort Myers, for appellant Heil.
Gerald W. Pierce of Henderson, Franklin, Starnes & Holt, Fort Myers, for appellee Bohac.
This is an appeal from an order denying a guardian's petition to make certain inter vivos gifts of her ward's property for estate and income tax planning purposes.
On September 29, 1976, the court appointed Doris Heil guardian of the person and property of Helen F. Bohac on grounds of mental incompetency. On December 20, 1978, Mrs. Heil filed a petition seeking authority to make inter vivos gifts of $400,000 out of an estate of $950,000. According to the petition, Mrs. Bohac, who was 78 years old, was a permanent resident of a nursing home where she was receiving good care. A doctor's report attached to the petition reflected the opinion that Mrs. Bohac was totally incompetent and would remain so. The proposed gifts would result in an income tax saving to the estate of about $15,000, and if Mrs. Bohac survived for three more years, the total estate tax savings would amount to approximately $26,000. Even after the gifts, Mrs. Bohac's after tax income would be more than twice her estimated annual cost of living.
The recipients of the gifts were to be two daughters of a sister of Mrs. Bohac's deceased husband, a daughter of the brother of Mrs. Bohac's stepmother and a nephew. The nephew was the only living blood relative of Mrs. Bohac. Mrs. Bohac had executed her last known will on March 12, 1975, and in that will she left her entire estate to her husband (now deceased) but provided that if he did not outlive her it would pass in equal shares to those of six named persons who survived her. The four persons designated to receive the inter vivos gifts were among the six persons who would inherit should she die. 1
The court appointed a guardian ad litem for Mrs. Bohac, and then, after hearing, it denied the petition. In the order of denial the court found that the individuals to whom the guardian wished to make gifts were not members of Mrs. Bohac's family and that the guardian had not shown a donative intent on the part of her ward.
There are no reported appellate decisions in Florida on the authority of a guardian to make gifts of her ward's property. However, many other jurisdictions have acknowledged the existence of such authority. Even without specific statutory authorization, a number of states have recognized the inherent power of the court to permit a guardian to make applications of funds of an incompetent for the benefit of the latter's relatives. 2 Where the ward had a legal obligation of support, the question was easy. 3 In those cases in which there was no legal obligation of support, the courts generally have based their power or that of the guardian upon findings with respect to what provision the incompetent herself would have made if she were sane. 4 This principle has been called the "doctrine of substituted judgment." 5 Under this principle, proposed inter vivos gifts for tax planning purposes have been both approved and disapproved. 6
In its new probate code, Florida has adopted a specific statute to deal with gifts for tax purposes. Section 744.441(17), Florida Statutes (1979), reads:
744.441 Powers of guardian upon court approval. After obtaining approval of the court in accordance with s. 744.447, a guardian of the property may:
(17) Make gifts of the ward's property to members of the ward's family in estate and income tax planning procedures.
The guardian ad litem seeks to uphold the order of denial primarily on the basis that the proposed recipients of the gifts are not members of Mrs. Bohac's family as the statute requires. While the guardian ad litem cannot point to a statutory definition of the word family, he argues that it should be limited to a spouse or blood relative. Since the legislature did not choose to define family, we are not inclined to impose an arbitrary definition. Rather, we believe that one's family may vary under the circumstances. In this connection, we find the case of In re Freeman's Estate, 171 Miss. 147, 157 So. 253 (1934), to be instructive. There, in upholding an order authorizing a guardian to pay a monthly allowance for the support of the ward's stepmother, the Supreme Court of Mississippi construed the word family as it appeared in the statute as follows:
The word "family," as defined by the lexicographers, is one of broad meaning and may include persons whom the ward, under normal conditions, would be under no legal duty to support. The measure of a guardian's authority to apply any part of the ward's estate to the maintenance and support of the...
To continue reading
Request your trial
-
Marriage of Drews by Drews, In re
...(1816), 2 Mer.Rep. 99, 35 Eng.Rep. 878; In re Buckley's Estate (1951), 330 Mich. 102, 47 N.W.2d 33; see also In re Guardianship of Bohac (Fla.App.Ct.1980), 380 So.2d 550 (gift for tax and estate planning purposes).) In its more contemporary conception the doctrine has been expanded in order......
-
John F. Kennedy Memorial Hosp., Inc. v. Bludworth
...the known facts and circumstances what the individual would want done if he were conscious and competent. See In re: Guardianship of Bohac, 380 So.2d 550 (Fla. 2d DCA 1980). Other jurisdictions confronted with this issue have used a variety of methods to determine intent. The issue appears ......
-
Rainey v. Guardianship of Mackey
...Court of Appeal has recognized that a guardian may transfer a disabled person's assets to reduce death taxes, see In re Guardianship of Bohac, 380 So.2d 550 (Fla. 2d DCA 1980), no Florida case has addressed a guardian's request to "spend down" an incompetent person's assets in order to qual......
-
Guardianship of Sherry, In re
...parties rely upon Goeke v. Goeke, 613 So.2d 1345, 1347 (Fla. 2d DCA), rev. denied, 621 So.2d 1065 (Fla.1993) and In re Guardianship of Bohac, 380 So.2d 550 (Fla. 2d DCA 1980). In Goeke, the ward had signed an individual retirement account (IRA) beneficiary designation listing his son John a......
-
Avoiding Living Probate
...(statute allowed gifts "in keeping with the ward's wishes so far as they can be ascertained") (emphasis supplied); Guardianship of Bohac, 380 So.2d 550, 552 (Fla.App. 1986) provided a guardian may "[m]ake gifts of the ward's property to members of the ward's family in estate and income tax ......