John Hood Co. v. American Pneumatic Service Co.

• Decision Date: 02 March 1906
• Citation: 191 Mass. 27,77 N.E. 638
• Parties: JOHN HOOD CO. v. AMERICAN PNEUMATIC SERVICE CO.
• Court: United States State Supreme Judicial Court of Massachusetts Supreme Court

191 Mass. 27

77 N.E. 638

JOHN HOOD CO. v. AMERICAN PNEUMATIC SERVICE CO.

Supreme Judicial Court of Massachusetts, Suffolk.

March 2, 1906

COUNSEL

Chas. G. Chick, for plaintiff.

Edwin C. Cilman and Jas. T. Pugh, for defendant.

OPINION

LATHROP, J.

The rules of law applicable to this case are well settled. A common carrier may limit its liability in case of loss by stipulating concerning the value of the property which it undertakes to convey; but this stipulation must be brought home to the knowledge of the shipper under such circumstances that his assent to it can fairly be assumed to have been given. And if he accepts and acts upon it without dissent he will be presumed to have agred to it. Graves v. Adams Express Co., 176 Mass. 280, 282, 57 N.E. 462, and cases cited. It is possible, but we think not probable, that the case was decided upon this ground.

A better ground to rest the decision upon is that there was evidence of ratification by the manager of the defendant company of the act of Green, the defendant's clerk. There was evidence that Green said to the treasurer of the plaintiff company, when he called at the office to see about the lost package, and asked to see the manager: 'It is unnecessary to see the manager, we are responsible, the receipt amounts to nothing. Go ahead and replace the goods, and if the bill is O. K., we will pay it.' There was also evidence that when the president of the plaintiff company saw later the manager of the defendant company and told him what Green had said, the manager said: 'Never mind now; I will look into it. You present your bill any way, and, if it is as you say, and a just bill, we will pay it.' No question was made at the trial as to the justness of the bill, and the only defense was the limitation of liability in the receipt to $5. Metcalf v. Williams, 144 Mass. 452, 11 N.E. 700, and cases cited.

Exceptions overruled.