Johnson v. State
Decision Date | 13 March 2014 |
Docket Number | No. 2010–CT–01978–SCT.,2010–CT–01978–SCT. |
Citation | 155 So.3d 733 |
Court | Mississippi Supreme Court |
Parties | Angela Denise JOHNSON a/k/a Angela Johnson v. STATE of Mississippi. |
Cynthia Ann Stewart, attorney for appellant.
Office of the Attorney General by Billy L. Gore, John R. Henry, Jr., attorneys for appellee.
EN BANC.
ON WRIT OF CERTIORARI
¶ 1. A Neshoba County jury convicted Angela Johnson of one count of possession of methamphetamine, one count of possession of precursor chemicals, and one count of false pretense. The Court of Appeals affirmed Johnson's convictions, and this Court granted certiorari to resolve the question of whether admission into evidence of two search warrants and an underlying facts-and-circumstances affidavit which included hearsay statements attributed to a confidential informant constituted reversible error. Because we find error, we reverse the judgments of the trial court and the Court of Appeals and remand the case to the Circuit Court of Neshoba County for a new trial.
Johnson v. State, 155 So.3d 822, 824–26 (Miss.Ct.App.2013).
¶ 2. The search warrants and accompanying documents were introduced by the State and admitted as substantive evidence at trial. Each included the following statement by the issuing justice court judge:
¶ 3. Attached to each search warrant was an underlying facts-and-circumstances affidavit, which included the curriculum vitae of Officer Sciple:
Affiant, Ralph Sciple has been in law enforcement since 1980. Sciple has served as Constable in Kemper County for 12 years, served with the DeKalb Police Department for 8 years, several of those years as Chief of Police and served as Sheriff of Kemper County for 1 ½ years. Sciple is presently serving with the Neshoba County Sheriff's Department where he has been for the past 10 plus years and has been an Investigator for over 9 of those years. Sciple is a certified law enforcement officer and a graduate of the Mississippi Law Enforcement Training Academy in Pearl, Mississippi and has attended numerous in service training on the subject of criminal investigations. Sciple has effected numerous felony arrests and investigated numerous cases. Sciple has applied for and received many search warrants in his career.
¶ 4. The underlying facts-and-circumstances affidavit attached to the search warrant for methamphetamine and precursor materials included the following:
Inv. Sciple has received information for the past several days from a confidential informant that Inv. Sciple knows to be a credible person and has given creditable information in the past that has led to arrest and convictions that Methamphetamine was being made at 10132 county road 369 at the residence of Angela D. Johnson. On this day 01–09–10 the same informant gave the following information that he/she saw lithium batteries, fertilizer, camp fuel, drain cleaner and plastic tubing at the residence of 10132 county road 369. The informant stated there was always Methamphetamine at the residence. On 01–09–10 Inv. Sciple began preparing an affidavit for Search Warrant, with supportive Underlying Facts and Circumstances, this being within the past 24 hours. It is based on these facts that your affiant respectfully request a search warrant be issued for this residence, 10132 Road 369 Philadelphia, MS 39350 to include all persons, outbuildings and vehicles.
¶ 5. Similarly, the underlying facts-and-circumstances affidavit attached to the search warrant for fake IDs and fake ID manufacturing equipment stated:
Inv. Sciple has received information for the past several days from a confidential informant that Inv. Sciple knows to be a credible person and has given credible information in the past that has led to arrest and convictions that Fake ID's were being made at 10132 county road 369 Philadelphia, MS 39350 at the residence of Angela D. Johnson. On this day 01–09–10 the same informant gave the following information that he/she saw Fake ID's made and other names on fake ID's at the residence of 10132 county road 369 Philadelphia, MS 39350. On 01–09–10 Inv. Sciple began preparing an affidavit for Search Warrant, with supportive Underlying Facts and Circumstances, this being within the past 24 hours. It is based on these facts that your affiant respectfully request a search warrant be issued for this residence, 10132 Road 369 Philadelphia, MS 39350 to include all persons, outbuildings and vehicles.
¶ 6. At trial, Johnson moved to suppress the search warrants on grounds of staleness and unreliability. Johnson objected repeatedly on the same grounds, and she renewed her previous objections in a motion for directed verdict. The trial court denied the motion to suppress, overruled the objections, and denied the motion for directed verdict. On direct appeal, Johnson challenged the search warrants, arguing that their admission at trial:
(1) allowed the informant to testify via hearsay that methamphetamine was being manufactured at the residence, (2) violated her right to confront the witness, (3) constituted “other crime evidence” inadmissible under Mississippi Rule of Evidence 404(b), and (4) permitted Officer Sciple to vouch for the credibility of the informant.2
Johnson, 155 So.3d at 826. The Court of Appeals held that the issues were procedurally barred because they were not raised before the trial court. Johnson, 155 So.3d at 827. See Walker v. State, 913 So.2d 198, 217 (Miss.2005) (); Montana v. State, 822 So.2d 954, 959 (Miss.2002) (...
To continue reading
Request your trial-
Wilson v. State
...affects a defendant's fundamental, substantive right” may be considered by the Court under the doctrine of plain error. Johnson v. State, 155 So.3d 733, 738 (Miss.2014) (quoting Burdette v. State, 110 So.3d 296, 303 (Miss.2013) ). “For the plain-error doctrine to apply, there must have been......
-
Rogers v. Thames
...reputation of judicial proceedings." Maness v. K & A Enters. of Miss. LLC , 250 So. 3d 402, 415 (¶47) (Miss. 2018) (quoting Johnson v. State , 155 So. 3d 733, 738-39 (¶8) (Miss. 2014). "The error also must be a deviation from a legal rule by the trial court that is plain, clear, obvious, an......
-
Green v. State
...miscarriage of justice or seriously affects the fairness, integrity or public reputation of judicial proceedings." Johnson v. State, 155 So.3d 733, 738 (Miss.2014) (citations omitted).¶ 13. Whether a convicted felon may be punished separately for possessing each individual firearm under Sec......
-
Maness v. K & A Enters. of Miss., LLC
...miscarriage of justice or seriously affects the fairness, integrity or public reputation of judicial proceedings." Johnson v. State , 155 So.3d 733, 738 (Miss. 2014). Above, we employ the de novo standard of review to the Manesses' claim that the trial court erred in granting summary judgme......