Moon Shadow, Inc. v. Director of Revenue

• Decision Date: 27 May 1997
• Docket Number: No. 79560,79560
• Citation: 945 S.W.2d 436
• Parties: MOON SHADOW, INC., Respondent, v. DIRECTOR OF REVENUE, Appellant.
• Court: Missouri Supreme Court

Page 436

945 S.W.2d 436

MOON SHADOW, INC., Respondent, v. DIRECTOR OF REVENUE, Appellant.

No. 79560.

Supreme Court of Missouri En Banc.

May 27, 1997.

Jeremiah W. (Jay) Nixon, Attorney General, Evan J. Buchheim, Assistant Attorney General, Jefferson City, for Appellant.

C. H. Parsons, Jr., Mary L. D. Griffith, Dexter, for Respondent.

PER CURIAM.

Moon Shadow, Inc., operates as a recreational concessionaire of the United States Park Service on the banks of the Current River, near Van Buren, Missouri. Moon Shadow bought over 1,000 truck and tractor inner tubes, paying sales tax at the time of purchase. Moon Shadow did not resell the tubes, but rented them to customers for floating the river. Moon Shadow modified some 400 of the inner tubes by adding an adjustable mesh seat and a metal ring for attaching a cooler. The tubes are propelled by the river's current, and occasionally by paddle. Moon Shadow transports the customer and the tube to a "put-in" point, where they float downstream to Moon Shadow's location, and return the tube.

Auditing for the summers of 1992, 1993, and 1994, the Director assessed Moon Shadow $15,243.80 in sales tax on the tube rentals, plus interest at the statutory rate, but with no additions. The Administrative Hearing Commission determined that Moon Shadow was not liable for the assessment. This Court has jurisdiction of the Director's petition for review. Mo. Const. art. V, sec. 3; sec. 621.189. ¹ The decision of the Commission "shall be upheld when authorized by law and supported by competent and substantial evidence upon the whole record." Sec. 621.193. Affirmed.

Section 144.020, subd. 1 creates the sales tax:

A tax is hereby levied and imposed upon all sellers for the privilege of engaging in the business of selling tangible personal property or rendering taxable service at retail in this state. The rate of tax shall be as follows:

. . . . .

(8) A tax equivalent to four percent of the amount paid or charged for rental or lease of tangible personal property....

Moon Shadow paid sales tax on the inner tubes when it bought them. The Administrative Hearing Commission rejected sales tax on the tube rentals, invoking the language of section 144.020, subd. 1(8) immediately following that quoted above:

provided that if the lessor or renter of any tangible personal property had previously purchased the property under the conditions of "sale at retail" as defined in subdivision (8) of section 144.010 and the tax was paid at the time of purchase, the lessor or renter shall not apply or collect the tax on the subsequent lease or rental receipts from that property.

The Director argues that Moon Shadow owes sales tax on its rental charges, claiming they are "fees paid to, or in any place of amusement, entertainment or recreation, games and athletic events." Sec. 144.020, subd. 1(2). An essential element is the existence of a place of amusement, entertainment or recreation. See Spudich v. Director of Revenue, 745 S.W.2d 677, 680 (Mo. banc 1988). According to the Director, that place here is either Moon Shadow's business location, or an eight-mile stretch of the Current River.

The General Assembly did not intend a "broad and strained construction" of the term "place of amusement." L & R Distributing Inc. v. Missouri Dep't of Revenue, 529 S.W.2d 375, 378 (Mo.1975). "Words used in statutes, absent statutory definition, are given their plain and ordinary meaning derived from the dictionary." Spudich, 745 S.W.2d at 680. A "place" is "a building or locality used for a special purpose ." Webster's Third New International Dictionary 1727 (1976). In the cases cited by the Director, the place...