Salter v. Alfa Ins. Co., Inc.
Decision Date | 12 April 1990 |
Parties | Betty SALTER v. ALFA INSURANCE COMPANY, INC. 88-1497. |
Court | Alabama Supreme Court |
Allen G. Woodard of Cherry & Givens, Dothan, for appellant.
William C. Carn III and Connie Ray Stockham of Lee & McInish, Dothan, for appellee.
After Betty Salter's agent's contract was terminated by Alfa Insurance Company, Inc. ("Alfa"), she sued Alfa, claiming that the contract had been wrongfully terminated and that she had been defrauded. The trial court entered a summary judgment for Alfa on both claims, 1 and certified it as final pursuant to Rule 54(b), Ala.R.Civ.P. 2 Salter appealed. We affirm.
Initially, we note that the summary judgment was appropriate in this case if there was no genuine issue of material fact and Alfa was entitled to a judgment as a matter of law. In determining whether there was a genuine issue of material fact, this Court must review the evidence in the light most favorable to Salter and resolve all reasonable doubts against Alfa. Kizziah v. Golden Rule Insurance Co., 536 So.2d 943 (Ala.1988). This action was pending on June 11, 1987; therefore, the applicable standard of review is the "scintilla of evidence rule." Ala.Code 1975, § 12-21-12.
Salter argues that the trial court erred in entering the summary judgment on her wrongful termination claim on the ground that her employment contract with Alfa was terminable at will. We disagree.
Salter alleged that Alfa's termination of her contract was wrongful because it was based upon a finding by Alfa that she had not cooperated in the investigation of a life insurance claim that had been filed with Alfa in connection with the death of W.B.; Salter alleged that she had been told by a representative of Alfa that she did not have to be involved in the investigation of the W.B. claim and that she had relied upon that representation. The undisputed evidence showed that Salter had an employment contract with Alfa that was terminable at the will of either party. 3 She argues, nonetheless, that the termination of her contract was in violation of this state's public policy because, she says, the Legislature has historically treated the insurance industry "with a view to the public interest." Salter asks that we carve a public policy exception out of the rule in this state that an employment contract at will may be terminated by either party with or without cause or justification. In Hinrichs v. Tranquilaire Hospital, 352 So.2d 1130 (Ala.1977), this Court was faced with the question whether the plaintiff could maintain an action in tort for the termination of her employment contract, which was terminable "at will," based on her claim that the termination was the result of her refusal to continue to falsify medical records and, therefore, that it was "wrongful." We held that she could not, and affirmed the summary judgment entered for the defendants, stating, in pertinent part, as follows:
352 So.2d at 1131-32. Recently, in Bosarge v. Bankers Life Co., 541 So.2d 499, 501 (Ala.1989), involving a suit alleging breach of contract, this Court, quoting Hoffman-LaRoche, Inc. v. Campbell, 512 So.2d 725, 728 (Ala.1987), declined to modify the employee-at-will doctrine, stating, in pertinent part, as follows:
(Some emphasis in original; some emphasis added in Bosarge.)
Again, we decline to modify the employee-at-will doctrine by recognizing a public policy exception to it in this case. The trial court did not err in entering the summary judgment on the wrongful termination claim on the ground that Salter had an employment contract that was terminable at will.
Salter next contends that the trial court erred in entering the summary judgment on her fraud claim because, she argues, there was at least a scintilla of evidence tending to prove each element of the claim. Again, we disagree.
Salter's complaint, in pertinent part, reads as follows:
The record shows that Alfa made a prima facie showing that Salter's allegations were unsubstantiated and, therefore, that it was entitled to a judgment as a matter of law. Accordingly, the burden shifted to Salter to present at least a scintilla of evidence tending to show the existence of a fact question. In an attempt to do this, Salter presented evidence tending to show that Sandy Godwin, the director of life insurance claims for Alfa, had told her that Alfa was "not going to involve [her] in the investigation [of W.B.'s death], because of the closeness that [she] had with [W.B.'s] family." The evidence also tended to show that Salter had relied on that representation by staying out of the investigation and that she had been told that Alfa terminated her contract because she did not cooperate in the investigation.
The elements of actionable fraud based on a misrepresentation are: (1) a duty to speak the truth; (2) a false representation of a material existing fact made intentionally, recklessly, or innocently; (3) action upon the false representation by the plaintiff; and (4) damages proximately resulting from the false representation. Alfa...
To continue reading
Request your trial-
Farmers Ins. Exch. v. Morris
...his or her employer.’ See, Burrell v. Carraway Methodist Hospitals of Alabama, Inc., 607 So.2d 193, 196 (Ala.1992) ; Salter [v. Alfa Ins. Co., 561 So.2d 1050 (Ala.1990) ]. For example, in Salter, the plaintiff alleged that her employer represented that she did not have to be involved in inv......
-
Carl v. Children's Hosp., 93-CV-1476.
...respect thereto (in view of the limited discovery sought as well as its relevancy to retaliation charge). 1 See also Salter v. Alfa Ins. Co., 561 So.2d 1050, 1052 (Ala.1990) (rejecting public policy exception to employment-at-will doctrine because "such creations are best left to the legisl......
-
Curtis 1000, Inc. v. Youngblade
...141, 148 (Tex.1991) (concurring opinion, recognizing the Texas also finds public policy in judicial decisions); Salter v. Alfa Ins. Co., 561 So.2d 1050, 1056 (Ala.1990); Watson v. Cleveland Chair Co., 789 S.W.2d 538, 540 (Tenn.1989) (including judicial decisions among the sources of public ......
-
Thompto v. Coborn's Inc.
...141, 148 (Tex.1991) (concurring opinion, recognizing the Texas also finds public policy in judicial decisions); Salter v. Alfa Ins. Co., Inc., 561 So.2d 1050, 1056 (Ala.1990); Watson v. Cleveland Chair Co., 789 S.W.2d 538, 540 (Tenn.1989) (including judicial decisions among the sources of p......
-
Related State Torts
...a wrongful termination lawsuit). Other states not recognizing the public policy exception are: • Alabama : Salter v. Alfa Ins. Co. , 561 So.2d 1050, 1052 (Ala. 1990) • Georgia : Evans v. Bibb Co. , 178 Ga. App. 139, 342 S.E.2d 484, 485-486 (1986) • Mississippi : Perry v. Sears, Roebuck & Co......