State ex rel. Carpenter v. Warren Municipal Court
Citation | 400 N.E.2d 391,15 O.O.3d 225,61 Ohio St.2d 208 |
Decision Date | 13 February 1980 |
Docket Number | No. 79-969,79-969 |
Parties | , 15 O.O.3d 225 The STATE ex rel. CARPENTER, Appellant, v. WARREN MUNICIPAL COURT et al., Appellees. |
Court | Ohio Supreme Court |
In September of 1978, the relator, Alberta J. Carpenter, filed a complaint in forcible entry and detainer in the Warren Municipal Court, seeking to gain possession of certain real property located in Warren Township, Trumbull County. In October of that year, the defendant in that action, Martha Meadors, filed a motion to dismiss the complaint or, in the alternative, to stay proceedings in the Municipal Court case pending the outcome of a previously filed action in the Court of Common Pleas of Trumbull County involving the same real property and the same parties as the Municipal Court action.
The action in the common pleas court seeks relief by way of setting aside a deed conveying the subject real property from Meadors to Carpenter, for the reason that execution of this deed was obtained by false and fraudulent means. This deed has been recorded in the Trumbull County Records of Deeds.
On November 15, 1978, the Municipal Court ordered that this action be stayed pending determination of the action in the Court of Common Pleas as to title.
Relator then sought a writ of procedendo from the Court of Appeals for Trumbull County, directing the Municipal Court to proceed to judgment in the forcible entry and detainer action.
The appellate court denied the writ, and relator appeals to this court as a matter of right.
Roy A. Mimna, Warren, for appellant.
William P. McLain, law director, and James R. Ries, Warren, for appellees.
This court, in Haas v. Gerski (1963), 175 Ohio St. 327, 194 N.E.2d 765, has dealt with the subject matter jurisdiction of Municipal Courts in actions sounding in forcible entry and detainer when title to such property is drawn into question in a collateral action in a common pleas court.
In that case, this court, at page 329, 194 N.E.2d at page 767, first considered the jurisdiction of a Municipal Court to hear and determine forcible entry and detainer actions:
To continue reading
Request your trial-
Ayer, In re
... ... In re AYER ... No. C-960488 ... Court of Appeals of Ohio, ... First District, Hamilton ... , supra, at 16, 520 N.E.2d at 1364; State ex rel. Ventrone v. Birkel (1981), 65 Ohio St.2d ... ...
-
State ex rel. GMS Management Co., Inc. v. Callahan
...Ohio Jurisprudence 2d (1957) 454, 455, Forcible Entry and Detainer, Section 2; see, also, State, ex rel. Carpenter v. Court (1980), 61 Ohio St.2d 208, 210, 15 O.O.3d 225, 226, 400 N.E.2d 391, 393. Further, " '[t]he Civil Rules will * * * be inapplicable if their application would frustrate ......
-
State ex rel. Corn v. Russo
... ... RUSSO, JUDGE, APPELLANT ... No. 00-23 ... Supreme Court of Ohio ... Submitted September 12, 2000 ... Decided January 17, ... ...
-
State ex rel. Tri Eagle Fuels L.L.C. v. Dawson
...forcible entry and detainer action despite a previously filed quiet title action based on fraud in State ex rel. Carpenter v. Warren Municipal Court, 61 Ohio St.2d 208, 400 N.E.2d 391 (1980). Similarly, in State ex rel. Brady v. Pianka , 106 Ohio St.3d 147, 2005-Ohio-4105, 832 N.E.2d 1202, ......