Gilbert v. Richardson, A93A2221

• Decision Date: 19 June 1995
• Docket Number: No. A93A2221,A93A2221
• Citation: 458 S.E.2d 405,217 Ga.App. 612
• Parties: GILBERT et al. v. RICHARDSON et al.
• Court: Georgia Court of Appeals

Page 405

458 S.E.2d 405

217 Ga.App. 612

GILBERT et al. v. RICHARDSON et al.

No. A93A2221.

Court of Appeals of Georgia.

June 19, 1995.

Sovereign immunity. Walker Superior Court. Before Judge Wood.

Hill & Henry, W. Ralph Hill, Jr., Lafayette, for appellants.

Leitner, Warner, Moffitt, Williams, Dooley, Carpenter & Napolitan, George W. Carpenter, Stuart F. James, Strang, Fletcher, Carriger, Walker, Hodge & Smith, Larry L. Cash, Chattanooga, TN, for appellees.

BLACKBURN, Judge.

In Gilbert v. Richardson, 211 Ga.App. 795, 440 S.E.2d 684 (1994), we affirmed the trial court's grant of summary judgment to the defendants on the grounds that they were immune to suit under the doctrine of sovereign immunity. The Supreme Court granted certiorari and affirmed in part and reversed in part our decision in Gilbert v. Richardson, 264 Ga. 744, 452 S.E.2d 476 (1994).

Prior to the 1991 amendment, Art. I, Sec. II, Par. IX of the 1983 Constitution provided for a waiver of sovereign immunity for any claim against "the state or any of its departments and agencies" to the extent of any liability insurance. Under the 1983 Constitution the courts interpreted the phrase "the state or any of its departments and agencies" to include counties, county school boards, municipalities, Board of Regents, and hospital authorities. See Hiers v. City of Barwick, 262 Ga. 129, 414 S.E.2d 647 (1992) (municipalities); Wilson v. Bd. of Regents, etc., of Ga., 262 Ga. 413, 419 S.E.2d 916 (1992) (Board of Regents); Culberson v. Fulton-DeKalb Hosp. Auth., 201 Ga.App. 347, 411 S.E.2d 75 (1991) (hospital authorities); Thigpen v. McDuffie County Bd. of Ed., 255 Ga. 59, 335 S.E.2d 112 (1985) (counties and county school boards).

The 1991 amendment to Art. I, Sec. II, Par. IX of the 1983 Georgia Constitution (1991 amendment) provided sovereign immunity extended to the "state and all of its departments and agencies," except to the extent provided for by the Georgia legislature. Under the Georgia Tort Claims Act (GTCA), although the "state" waives its sovereign immunity to the extent of insurance, the statute specifically excludes "counties, municipalities, school districts, other units of local government, [or] hospital authorities" from the definition of "state." OCGA § 50-21-22(5).

The Supreme Court has construed differently the same phrase contained in the pre-1991 amendment versus the post-1991 amendment for the apparent purpose of changing the impact of the GTCA. The Supreme Court has determined that the 1991 amendment does include counties but does not include municipalities. See Gilbert v. Richardson, 264 Ga. 744, 452 S.E.2d 476, supra (1991 amendment includes counties); City of Thomaston v. Bridges, 264 Ga. 4, 439 S.E.2d 906 (1994) (1991 amendment does not include municipalities).

In this case, the plaintiffs brought suit against the Walker County sheriff and deputy sheriff seeking damages for injuries sustained in a collision with the deputy sheriff while the deputy was responding to an emergency call. The Supreme Court noted that it had previously determined that the phrase "state or any of its departments or agencies" contained in former Art. I, Sec. II, Par. IX of the 1983 Georgia Constitution included counties of the State of Georgia. The Court reasoned that "[t]he language used in the 1991 amendment is virtually identical to that used in the 1983 amendment to describe the entities to which sovereign immunity applies.... [Therefore,] [a]bsent any evidence that the legislature intended a different interpretation or to indicate that the electorate did not intend to extend sovereign immunity to counties, we hold the 1991 amendment's extension of sovereign immunity to 'the state and its departments and agencies' must also apply to counties. See Bibb County v. Hancock, 211 Ga. 429, 432 (86 SE2d 511) (1955); Thompson v. Talmadge, 201 Ga. 867, 885 (41 SE2d 883) (1947) (courts should accord virtually identical language in successor provisions the same construction given the original language); see also Thomas v. Hosp. Auth. of Clarke County, 264 Ga. 40 (440 SE2d 195) (1994) (identifying counties as departments or agencies of the state)." Gilbert, supra at 747, 452 S.E.2d 476.

However, the Supreme Court disregarded its opinion in City of Thomaston, where it interpreted the phrase "the state and all of its departments and agencies" as contained in the 1991 amendment so as not to include municipalities. City of Thomaston, supra at 7, 439 S.E.2d 906. The Court reasoned, "although in Hiers we construed the language in former Art. I, Sec. II, Par. IX to include municipalities, we cannot allow that construction, which effectuated the intent behind the 1983 provision, to bind this Court to a construction which directly conflicts with the obvious intent of the drafters of the 1991 amendment and contravenes the cardinal rule of construction." City of Thomaston, supra at 6, 439 S.E.2d 906.

The Supreme Court in City of Thomaston inferred that the intent of the 1991 amendment was "manifest...