McFadden Business Publications, Inc. v. Guidry
Decision Date | 10 February 1986 |
Docket Number | No. 71139,71139 |
Citation | 341 S.E.2d 294,177 Ga.App. 885 |
Parties | McFADDEN BUSINESS PUBLICATIONS, INC. et al. v. GUIDRY. |
Court | Georgia Court of Appeals |
John V. Burch, Atlanta, for appellants.
John E. Talmadge, Atlanta, and David S. Bohannon, Marietta, for appellee.
On Saturday, June 5, 1982 appellee Guidry sustained head injuries when he fell while cutting down a tree on the premises of appellant McFadden Business Publications, Inc. (MBP). Appellee had a contract with MBP to cut down four dead trees at the company's place of business. After appellee sustained his injuries, he filed a claim with the State Board of Workers' Compensation seeking benefits from MBP and its insurer for his injuries. However, the Board held that appellee was acting as an independent contractor at the time of his accident and denied his claim. The Board's decision was affirmed on appeal to the superior court, and an application for discretionary appeal was subsequently denied by this court. Appellee then filed this lawsuit against MBP and its president, appellant Bradford McFadden, Jr., individually, seeking recovery in tort and also breach of contract. In response to appellee's lawsuit, appellants moved for a motion for partial summary judgment as to the tort claim on the principle of res judicata on the ground that there had been a prior adjudication of the same facts involving the same parties by the State Board of Workers' Compensation. This motion was denied by the trial court on the ground that the Board's decision could not affect a subsequent civil action filed in superior court. Appellants then filed an application for interlocutory appeal which was granted. This appeal followed.
The facts of record show that appellee was employed as a binderyman at MBP and had occupied that position for approximately three years prior to the accident on June 5, 1982. His normal working hours were Monday through Friday, 8:15 a.m. to 4:45 p.m. Appellee had a reputation at the company for having experience in tree cutting and in the past had sold fire wood to fellow workers at MBP. He had also done some previous tree-cutting work for the company. MBP's executive vice-president Whatley noticed in June of 1982 that there were some trees on the company's premises that were dead and/or dying and needed to be cut down. Since appellee had done work for the company in the past, he was asked if he would be interested in taking the dead trees down. Appellee said he was interested in doing the work and elected to do it on his own time for a flat fee, as opposed to performing it as overtime. Whatley then showed appellee the four trees he felt needed to be cut down. Appellee concurred with Whatley that the trees needed to be removed. Appellee was to stack the wood from the cut trees, which would be picked up later by appellant McFadden for his own use.
On the morning of the accident, appellee and a friend who was helping him arrived at the company premises at approximately 10:00 a.m. Appellee brought all his own equipment to perform his work. Neither MBP nor McFadden supplied any equipment or personnel to appellee, nor did they supervise his work in any way other than Whatley's admonishment to him to be careful and not to "tear anything up." The accident occurred when appellee climbed up the first tree to be cut. Appellee was using spike attachments to his boots to help him climb up the tree. While in the tree, he tied a rope around the tree in order to prevent the tree from falling on the company's building after it was cut. After the rope was secured to the tree, appellee began backing down the tree when he fell either because the rope broke or he lost his footing. The rope that broke when appellee fell from the tree had been borrowed from his uncle the night before. He fell approximately 30 feet out of the tree.
1. In denying appellee's claim for benefits, the State Board of Workers' Compensation made the following findings of fact: This award became final after the denial of all appeals. In the case at bar appellee alleges that at the time of the accident he was an employee of both appellants MBP and McFadden and that they owed him certain duties which were breached, rendering them liable. In their motion for summary judgment appellants argue that the Board's award is res judicata on the issue of whether appellee at the time of his accident was an employee or an independent contractor.
(a) Appellee questions whether appellants properly raised their res judicata defense on motion for summary judgment where the defense had not been affirmatively pled in the answer. See OCGA § 9-11-8(c). " Brown v. Moseley, 175 Ga.App. 282, 283, 333 S.E.2d 162 (1985). See Beazley v. Williams, 231 Ga. 137(1), 200 S.E.2d 751 (1973). The issue of res judicata was properly before the trial court for resolution.
(b) "Res judicata" is a broad term which includes the doctrine of estoppel by judgment. Mills v. Roberts, 172 Ga.App. 77, 78, 322 S.E.2d 93 (1984). Both doctrines are applicable to awards of the State Board of Workers' Compensation on all questions of fact in matters in which it has jurisdiction. Greene v. Transport Ins. Co., 169 Ga.App. 504(1), 313 S.E.2d 761 (1984). In order to apply in a subsequent suit after the termination of a previous action, both doctrines require an identity of parties and an adjudication on the merits by a court of competent jurisdiction. See Usher v. Johnson, 157 Ga.App. 420, 278 S.E.2d 70 (1981). The distinction between the two is that res judicata also requires an identity of the cause of...
To continue reading
Request your trial-
In re Betts
...806, 808, 209 S.E.2d 250 (1974); see also Bradshaw v. Glass, 252 Ga. 429, 314 S.E.2d 233 (1984); McFadden Business Publications, Inc. v. Guidry, 177 Ga.App. 885, 888, 341 S.E.2d 294 (1986). The burden of proof on this issue rested on Plaintiff as claimant and he benefitted from no presumpti......
-
Ga. Power Co. v. Brandreth Farms, LLC.
...in connection with the answer or by motion for summary judgment there is no waiver."), quoting McFadden Business Publications v. Guidry , 177 Ga. App. 885, 887 (1) (a), 341 S.E.2d 294 (1986).16 (Punctuation omitted.) Mayer v. Wylie , 229 Ga. App. 282, 283 (2), 494 S.E.2d 60 (1997), quoting ......
-
Chrison v. H & H INTERIORS, INC.
...or by motion for summary judgment there is no waiver." (Citations and punctuation omitted.) McFadden Business Publications v. Guidry, 177 Ga.App. 885, 887(1)(a), 341 S.E.2d 294 Here, defendants filed their motion for summary judgment on March 18, 1997, more than 30 days prior to the May 2, ......
-
Mendelson v. Se. Mortg. of Ga., Inc.
...court "necessarily" decides issues that are appropriate in justifying the remedy that it orders. See McFadden Bus. Publ'ns, Inc. v. Guidry, 177 Ga. App. 885, 888, 341 S.E.2d 294, 297 (1986). It is not a defense to a claim of issue preclusion that a court's ruling could have been narrower. S......
-
Workers' Compensation - H. Michael Bagley, Daniel C. Kniffen, John G. Blackmon, Jr., and Phillip Comer Griffeth
...See generally Ervin v. Swift Adhesives, Inc., 208 Ga. App. 265, 430 S.E.2d 133 (1993); McFadden Business Publications, Inc. v. Guidry, 177 Ga. App. 885, 341 S.E.2d 294 (1986) (collateral estoppel doctrine applicable to hearings of State Board of Workers' Compensation). The SSDI proceeding w......
-
Torts - Cynthia Trimboli Adams and Charles R. Adams Iii
...at 571. 307. Id. at 36, 459 S.E.2d at 571. 308. Id. 309. Id. at 37,459 S.E.2d at 572 (citing McFadden Business Publications v. Guidry, 177 Ga. App. 885, 341 S.E.2d 294 (1986); Reese Realty Co. v. Pal Realty Co., 182 Ga. App. 215, 355 S.E.2d 125 (1987)). 310. Id. 311. Id. 312. Id. at 37-38, ......
-
Trial Practice and Procedure - C. Frederick Overby and Teresa T. Abell
...at 571. 307. Id. at 36, 459 S.E.2d at 571. 308. Id. 309. Id. at 37,459 S.E.2d at 572 (citing McFadden Business Publications v. Guidry, 177 Ga. App. 885, 341 S.E.2d 294 (1986); Reese Realty Co. v. Pal Realty Co., 182 Ga. App. 215, 355 S.E.2d 125 (1987)). 310. Id. 311. Id. 312. Id. at 37-38, ......